Photos & videos
Review Highlights
“As for creating the ceremony, Jeffrey did a great job of getting to know us as individuals and who we are as a couple.” in 8 reviews
“p. I highly recommend him as an officiant (if you're going the non-religious route) and a counselo” in 4 reviews
“I appreciate how great our relationship has developed over the years and I am incredibly grateful for all his advice.” in 6 reviews
You Might Also Consider
in Behavior Analysts
in Counseling & Mental Health
in Counseling & Mental Health
About the Business
Business owner information
Jeffrey S.
Innovative, no nonsense approach to counseling which draws upon proven systems of psychology, science and metaphysics. From Cognitive Behavioral to Jungian resources, Creative Counseling is about following YOUR process and making change a reality in your life.
Location & Hours
Amenities and More
Ask the Community
Yelp users haven’t asked any questions yet about Jeffrey Sumber.
Recommended Reviews
Overall rating
20 reviews
5 stars
4 stars
3 stars
2 stars
1 star
- Feb 21, 2014
I originally approached Jeffrey because of relationship problems I was having. I wanted to go in for couples counseling, but my girlfriend wanted nothing to do with it but I went in myself anyway. I am so pleased that I did, and I have been speaking with Jeffrey off and on for several years now.
On the surface, what seemed like what I was going in for was help salvaging a tumultuous relationship, it soon became evident that I was really there for self-improvement; all of us can benefit from this, nobody is perfect. Over time, as Jeffrey and I got to know each other better, he was able to help guide me in a more positive direction with myself.
Jeffrey is a placid and compassionate individual. He is very thoughtful with his words and his approach to therapy; you'll never feel like you're a patient on a shrinks couch. He'll speak with you rather that at you in order to help you through whatever problems you may be having. It's important not to be defensive and to be receptive to his counseling. He is always trying to help you.
Even today, since I have left Chicago, Jeffrey has always made himself available for whenever I felt like I needed to speak with someone. I appreciate how great our relationship has developed over the years and I am incredibly grateful for all his advice. It is important to find someone that you feel is right for you, but highly recommend going in for a consultation.. you certainly will not regret it.Helpful 1Thanks 0Love this 1Oh no 0 - J L.San Marcos, CA06May 14, 2018
He hurt more than he helped. This counselor has his own issues. It's more his therapy than yours. We would zone out. I timed the 35 min of our session he talked at us and used "I, me or My Wife..." terms, but we wanted to give it a chance, being patient because it's a process.
We found him to be Misogynistic, smug and distant. We didn't feel like he was listening, but rather lecturing to no one in particular. Personalities don't always mesh, but we would not recommend this counselor.Helpful 1Thanks 0Love this 0Oh no 0 - Jenna S.Chicago, IL3327942May 4, 2010Updated review
In follow up to the comment on my review...If one prides themselves on such "high ethical standards," they would have opted not to post a response including false and defamatory claims about a former patient.
His comment only further confirms the statements which I've made regarding the way Jeffrey chooses to conduct himself.
The facts listed are very cut and dry, judge for yourself.Helpful 17Thanks 0Love this 1Oh no 1Apr 27, 2010Previous reviewSo, I told myself that I would wait before writing this review and if in several months I felt passionate about it, would write the scathing review Jefrrey Sumber deserves. It's been 10 months since our ordeal with him and I can honestly say neither my boyfriend or I have forgotten the way we were treated.
Our experience started out in March 2009 when I read Yelp's "ROTD" which glowingly talked about Jeffrey and his services. My boyfriend and I had been together for three years and were looking to move to the "next level" in our relationship. I emailed Jeffrey since several of the reviews mention a free intro session and inquired about setting this up. He informed me he does not do free intro sessions but would do a free "meet and greet" which would last approximately 15 minutes. On our first visit, the conversation flowed and Jeffrey kept us for approximately 45 minutes. Upon ending that visit, he expected payment in full for an entire session. This befuddled us because we'd specifically discussed a free "meet and greet" beforehand. It was incredibly awkward and we should have seen this as the first red flag; however, we felt comfortable with the rest of our discussions and eagerly signed up to attend weekly sessions. These weekly sessions were agreed to be paid upfront, out of pocket as he stated he does not file insurance.
Jeffrey only issues statements on a monthly basis, so by the time we were issued our first statement we had three therapy sessions under our belt racking up to the tune of $420. The first invoice we received listed Jeffrey's Blue Cross/Blue Shield Provider & NPI number at the bottom. After filing and receiving a determination from my insurance eight weeks later (keeping in mind, we're still seeing Jeffrey once a week at the cost of $140 per week) Blue Cross says that we should have received a provider discount and Jeffrey's "office" owes us $275 from the PPO discount.
When I emailed him to ask about the refund, he refused refund the money and actually denied the fact that he was a Blue Cross/Blue Shield Provider stating the PPO discount was not valid. He also remarked that he received things in the mail from them 'but just threw them away.' I had no other choice than to involve the Customer Advocate Department with BC/BS, which is when things with Jeffrey got ugly. He was obviously very angry at this and sent a string of emails expressing "how disappointed in us" he was. After I stopped responding to his hate mail, he started calling my boyfriend at work demanding an explanation as to why we were not going to continue our sessions with him. For the record, I should state that ALL of these emails and phone calls unfolded within the period of ONE day.
Additional repulsive facts you should know, during the last two weeks we attended (prior to the insurance determination) Jeffrey became increasingly aggressive towards discussing our sex life even after we'd expressed that we were not comfortable discussing it with him. The final two sessions were filled with nothing more than pressure to divulge our personal fantasies, leaving both my boyfriend and I feeling skeevy upon walking out of his office.
We also noted there were never other couples leaving his office, as a matter of fact...we never saw anyone there single or otherwise. In light of his excessive time to email and call when he thought he was losing $275, it became evident he really does have a lot of time on his hands.
Finally when Jeffrey was threatened with legal action by BC/BS, he sent us a check for the money which was owed and listed the account number listed on the memo line as "666." This account number did not match any of our account numbers listed on his invoices...but come on dude, how old ARE you?
In short, Jeffrey's services were nothing more than a simple mind ***k. As a matter of fact, reflecting back makes me doubt the validity of all the other reviews listed here. Please think twice about signing up for sessions with this individual. - Dee W.Evanston, IL18916001301May 1, 2007First to Review
So, the fiance and I hired Jeffrey Sumber to be our officiant and part of the costs require three pre-marital sessions. Since we wanted ours to be non-religious/secular, Jeffrey had asked us to come in so he could get to know us better and help us shape our ceremony to be befitting of us - what a great concept!
Our first intro session was FREE (yes, some things in life are free which is very very nice, especially if you're paying for a wedding anyway) and then, he also gave us a 50% discount after four pre-marital sessions with him - we've found his pre-marital sessions are extremely helpful - it's nice to have things laid out in a different manner. He's helping us see past the present and really help us lay out the foundation for our 'culture' together and for our lives together as one. He's also helping overcome little obstacles and something as silly as "why we fight over the center of the bed" - we're very confident in his abilities and look forward to having a beautiful ceremony that is catered to our personalities and our relationship.
I highly recommend him as an officiant (if you're going the non-religious route) and a counselor. Plus his office is right next door to Hopleaf and La Donna - another bonus right there, too! I'll probably add another addition to this review after the wedding ceremony.
EDIT: The above review was more so for our experience with Jeffrey as our officiant/pre-marital counselor but I've also worked with Jeffrey aside from that on some personal issues in addition to wedding preparation which includes my personal life, family, career, etc. He is very sincere and helpful in helping me reorganize myself and keep myself moving forward in a good way.Helpful 14Thanks 0Love this 10Oh no 0 - Paul K.Grand Rapids, MI1579757May 20, 2007
I met with Jeffrey for advice on my career and ended up gaining so much more from our meeting than I imagined. He is an extremely knowledgeable therapist with a broad background working with many different populations in a variety of settings. But what sets Jeffrey apart from many other therapists and counselors I have met is his genuine commitment to the basic and most important aspects of therapy--helping people THROUGH whatever issues/problems they are facing. I am someone who works in the mental health field and let me tell you that Jeffrey is unique in his approach. He doesn't expect you to sit on the couch for years and talk to the wall; he wants to work with you until you feel satisfied with your personal change.
In person, Jeffrey is engaged, willing to listen, and nonjudgemental. What's more, he takes an active approach in helping a person develop a vision for attainable and sustainable change in their lives. And after all, isn't that the point of therapy? If you're apprehensive about talking to another person about what's bothering you, then I highly recommend talking to Jeffrey. Trust me, it's worth it.Helpful 6Thanks 0Love this 3Oh no 0 - Steven D.Chicago, IL017Apr 16, 2013
I attended several sessions with Jeffrey Sumber, and ended up spending most of the time with an associate of his who had cheaper rates.
Briefly, my two disappointments in my interactions with Mr. Sumber are:
-He advertised a sliding scale for lower income clients. When I inquired about this in our first meeting he said he doesn't really offer a sliding scale anymore "because I don't have to." He subsequently paired me up with an associate with lower rates, which turned out well. I went to Mr. Sumber for several couples' sessions and then when that relationship ended I continued individual sessions with his associate.
-I had a preliminary individual session with him where he asked if I loved my girlfriend (at the time). I hesitated in my answer and he said, "don't worry, I won't ask you that in front of her." Subsequently in our first couples session he totally asked me that same question in front of her!! I was shocked!Helpful 7Thanks 0Love this 1Oh no 0 - Laura B.Chicago, IL1119Oct 8, 2007
Based on Dee's review, my now-husband and I set up an appointment with Jeffrey to see if he'd be the guy to hitch us. He was just perfect--he spent two sessions just getting to know us, and then tailor-made the ceremony for us over two more sessions (with our input, of course). It was personal, special, funny, and everything we'd wanted.
Best yet, though, was that Jeffrey was a professional. He knew just how to put together the ceremony, had a lot of suggestions for us, and did a beautiful job (I'm still getting compliments). It was so much nicer than having a friend who'd gotten ordained online do it--although that way is very personal and is probably lovely, it was reassuring to know we had a pro in our corner who was just as involved with us as a friend would have been.
Highly recommended, and thanks Dee!!Helpful 3Thanks 0Love this 3Oh no 0 - Jenica P.Des Plaines, IL48Dec 13, 2008
My Husband and I hired Jeffrey to officiate our October 11, 2008 wedding. As neither of us attend church and have no relationships with a reverend we set out to find someone who would take the time to get to know us as a couple and bring an element of personality to the ceremony.
We are so delighted that we found Jeffery. While we were unable to partake in the 3 sessions of pre-marital counseling we had a great first meeting (which is free!) with him and immediately felt that working together would be a great experience. We were given a ceremony builder workbook filed with questions meant to evoke deep thought in how we've gotten to this point in our relationship. It was so much fun to fill this out together and it brought us a new level of excitement in getting married.
By the day of the wedding I was so anxious to hear what Jeffrey had put together for us. It was so personal and touching, we felt as if he had known us for many many years, in-fact many guests later asked how long we'd known him for. All were surprised to find out that we had only met him after we were engaged.
Between being very accessible in the months leading up to the wedding and the calming sense of control and organization at the rehearsal and on the day of the wedding, Jeffrey is a great individual to help lead you into this new chapter of your life. I would and will recommend him to anyone looking for an officiant.
Thank you Jeffrey!Helpful 3Thanks 0Love this 1Oh no 0 - Mari G.Chicago, IL06Aug 2, 2017
Jeffrey is personable, intelligent, and talented at what he does. He has years upon years of experience, and it shows. I've had some of the most pivotal conversations of my life while chatting with this guy. He truly is someone that fosters personal growth and understanding every time you see him. Really grateful to know him.
Helpful 0Thanks 0Love this 0Oh no 0 - Maria M.Chicago, IL14472Aug 27, 2010
I started seeing Jeffrey in April and couldn't be happier with our counseling relationship. From the beginning, Jeffrey's been responsive and flexible, which is exactly what I needed. He's attentive to my needs and has been able to guide me to a better place in my life. Jeffrey's able to illustrate in such a manner that allows me to see life situations as I've never seen before, thus allowing me to grow into more of the person that I want to be.
I couldn't be happier that I randomly found him on the Psychology Today website. Not being in Chicago long, I didn't have many recommendations. So be it luck or providence, I'm thankful for having him in my life to help me sort it all out, and am looking toward a positive future.Helpful 0Thanks 0Love this 0Oh no 0
Other Counseling & Mental Health Nearby
in Pain Management, Counseling & Mental Health
in Counseling & Mental Health