Amazing food. What I like best is you can tell them the types of things you like and they will create something for you. They welcome suggestions, advice, sandwich naming and so on. Everything is prepared to look gorgeous and only the best ingredients are used. They sold me on cheese, but they are so much more than that. Join their Facebook page. I dare you to see a photo and not RUN to the store for some eats.

So NOT authentic New York. One of the kids said it was like little Caesars. Having been born and raised on New York City pizza, I'm a pizza snob but this was very casserole chain store pizza. nothing authentic ny here. Sad.

Been to both Johnny's now. Pizza is consistent at both. It's darn good. I'm born and raised in NY, the city part, and live with another New Yorker. We are pizza snobs and we love it. It lacks a little spice, and no New York water for that dough, but man it's that close. It's yum. Can't get enough. Makes it so when I get back home I don't RUN to the old neighborhood pizzeria. Friendly counter service too. Place is sweet, activities throughout the week, great looking place.

I'm a pizza snob. Born and raised in NY. I live with a New Yorker. Another pizza aficionado. I give it four stars and that's really high from me. It's not quite the pizza from the old neighborhood but it's damn close. IT Lacks a certain something. It lacks a little spice zing. And of course the NY water. But man, it's close. It's that good. Highly recommend