Sugar and Spice Bakery

We found this Gem of a Bakery and it's amazing!!
We love the Christmas Cookies especially! This is our second year buying gifts of trays of cookies! Delicious and Beautiful decorated!!
So many choices ! The Red Velvet Cookies are my
favorite!!
Their pies are also delicious!! Go support this wonderful small family business in Plano!!

My husband & son took me here at my request for a tea-room-like lunch for Mother's Day weekend. I ordered the finger sandwiches (came with chips), fruit cup, thumbprint sugar cookie with icing, and lemon bar with hot tea. I loved the presentation despite the fact it was on a paper plate! It was made beautiful with the doily and accented with a two carrots, pickles & olives. The fruit was a great variety, cut up small so as it was easy to eat, and extremely fresh! The thumbprint cookie was so soft and delicious and one was plenty to satisfy my sweet tooth. Thus, I saved the lemon bar for later. My only comment on what would have made it perfect would be if it had been served on China and my hot tea with a nice China tea cup instead of a styrofoam cup.

I bought petit fours for my Mother's Day event I hosted and they were beautiful and tasted great!

I'm definitely going to go to this bakery/restaurant again!

This is where my wife sends me for Specially made cupcakes and cookies whenever she is having an event like a baby shower. She picked up a homemade apple pie for Thanksgiving that was spectacular.

This is a local spot with delicious treats. I feel like that really needs to be said. I've only had the cookies and petit fours, but they really are out of this world. Sugar and Spice is a great place to get decorated treats for the family, but I would hesitate to purchase something for a party or gift because the appearance isn't the same quality you would see from a professional bakery.

My father claimed "the best Italian cream cake he's ever had". So fresh, moist and rich. Can't wait to order here again.

Excellent lunch menu. The food and pastries are delicious. Simple enjoyable atmosphere. Will go back again and again.

Wonderful!!! Exquisite!!! What this fabulous bakery did for me was way beyond the call of duty for anyone.
The owner ( please forgive me, can't remember your precious name), you and your staff are incredible!!
Called asking if they could make 2 birthday cakes and a birthday pecan pie. But, that's not the easy part! One cake was vanilla wedding cake with the Minnesota gopher mascot and colors. The other cake was chocolate on chocolate with UConn's mascot and colors. The pie was amazing! Perfect pecan pie, (oh my gosh, order early for Thanksgiving and Christmas- - REALLY), it had Bevo with orange and white colors. I'm telling you, you wouldn't believe how moist and delicious the cakes were. The PECAN PIE was out of this world!!
Of course, had to have a couple of chocolate chip cookies YUM! Mom could never make them this good. Mom's were really good, however these could win competitions.
Inside they have sandwiches, soups and salads . They might have more, it smells like home.
If your looking for quality baked goods or lunch or p/u dinner . Do yourself a favor. STOP HERE. Tell the lovely owner, you found him on Yelp from a review a grateful customer left about Sugar & Spice!
P. S. I'm serious about the pecan pie @ holidays.

Best Bakery in Plano! We go here regularly and take friends as well. Friendly and such a wonderful place

Cute place been there a long time nice place to get a tea lunch and amazing desserts!! My favorite thumbprint cookies around!

Over the years, several people I know and trust have recommended I try Sugar and Spice Bakery. But I'm a loyalist, and Millstone is OUR bakery. Nevertheless, I was on the hunt for really good petit fours (because sometimes you just want a piece of cake and in a two-person household, it can be a pain to work through a larger cake). So I gave Sugar and Spice a try.

The shop itself, even in the midst of a pandemic, reminds me of a small tea shop - a place where you ought to meet up with lady friends (or guy friends who enjoy homey cutesy spots) for a cup of tea and a sweet treat. I was surprised to discover they offer lunch, but not at all surprised to discover it was tea house style offerings - pimento cheese, chicken salad and so on. Immediately I regretted not making my exploratory trip at lunchtime. Because pimento cheese.

Anyway, I picked up a couple of petit fours since that's what I came to try. They offer them in chocolate and vanilla. I'd arrived close to closing time, so only vanilla was available. I figured I owed my family, and Yelp, a duty to try other things so I also bought buttercream iced sugar cookies, a ginger cookie and a frosted oatmeal cranberry cookie.

I needn't have feared cheating on Millstone by coming here. Sugar and Spice is more of a sweet bakery - pies, cookies, cupcakes and so on. Millstone is primarily a bakery, with French-style treats. Different lanes, allowing me to be loyal to each.

On to what we thought of the goodies:
* Ginger cookie - nice and on the softer side (but I wouldn't call it soft, though a 5 second microwave would have made it quite tender). The ginger was well-balanced. Husband proclaimed this a winner.
* Oatmeal cranberry cookie - nice and tasty, but nothing special. That's ok, you don't have to like everything.
* Buttercream iced sugar cookies - I planned to eat a half and save a half. I ate the whole thing. It was that good. And the icing wasn't dried out either (remember - I was there at the end of the business day!)
* Petit fours - oh man. These were amazing. Tender cake, almond-infused frosting. Winner, winner, winner. No more wishing Stein's Bakery was closer.

Will we be back? Yes. The husband's already instructed me to buy slices of pie so he can test their baking skills. As an epic home pie baker, I'm slightly offended by this directive but also relieved since I don't always have time/energy to make a pie whenever one is wanted.