Sarah's Pizza & Subs

Not really impressed. Cheap ingredients and just had a funny taste to it. I had a deluxe pizza. They use the small sausage bits. Actually the pizza tasted better cold the next morning. The sauce makes the pizza in my opinion and theirs was definitely from a can. The crust is very doughy not Crisp at all. Quality of ingredients just not there. This place came highly recommended. I would try their sandwiches next time but I think I'll pass on the pizza.

Sorry, I can't recommend this place. It's been an "only option" for so long that I don't think most people realize how over priced it is. I'd much rather drive and pickup Ron's Pizza in Camden.

Someone has made a bad business decision. I've been a regular, eating Sarah's practically every week. It was priced reasonably, tasty, and easy to order my regular meal online, prepay, and I could just walk in and pick it up ... they even recognized me usually and handed me my dinner as soon as I came in. Tonight though, I find out that something has changed and I can't order online any more (can't proceed to checkout) unless my order is over $10, which it's not since I'm ordering a sub sandwich and side for myself as usual. So I'm being told my order is "too small" to bother with, which means instead I had to either get on the phone and take my time (and theirs) to place the order, or go there and waste my time (and theirs) to place the same order and wait for it. There's a sign in the lobby thanking customers for supporting a small business ... the little guy ... but I guess my order is too small to be worthwhile any more. And I'm certainly not going to add on food I don't want just to be able to do it online. Why should I, when there's plenty of other restaurants in town. Very disappointed. I'll check their website occasionally to see if the policy has changed, but if I can't order from Sarahs, the apps for other restaurants in town work just fine.

Wow! For a small establishment (Located in at least two towns) the pizza blows the competition out of the arena.

I'm always looking for the best pizza experience around, and with all of the pizza I have had all over the world, Sarah's ranks up there among the Gold standard of Pizza joints.

The ingredients are F-R-E-S-H! The crust is outstanding! There's a healthy balance of ingredients to give one the best pizza experience they can find in Preble County. I truly love how the sauce does not overpower the taste of the other ingredients.

Crispy crust edges make the pizza that much more tasty. If you feel like staying in, they deliver! Try a pie! You won't be disappointed.

Great pizza at this pizza place. Unfortunately they take the phone off the hook when there delivery orders get backed up. Which sucks for those of us willing to use carry out. I ended up using my papa johns app Sunday instead. My normal recommendation is to call 20-30 min after they open and order the pizza at the time you want it later that day. It's nice that they do this for you. Over all it's a 4 star place that would be five if they got more help or fixed there ordering process.

Great food for the price especially. One of the biggest values for eating out in Eaton. Pizza is decent. Subs are fantastic!

My family ordered three pizzas for takeout tonight, and it was once again "decent". I'm *tempted* to bump it to 4 stars, as they've got a few creative/unique pizzas (like Chicken Ranch and Taco), but it still just has a typical pizza taste that definitely says "a-ok". One of the pizzas we ordered - mashed potato - was literally a pizza crust with mashed potatoes, chives, bacon, and cheese. It also came with IMITATION sour cream, which was too bad, as it was a bit of a turn-off that it wasn't actual sour cream. Again, the only indie pizza place in town, so I'll continue to give it my business when I'm craving pizza in Eaton.

I ordered a cheese stick pizza and extra large pepperoni it was 22.99 a dollar tax best pizza I ever had very good pricing fast delivery friendly staff