Menu
Popular dishes
People also searched for
Location & Hours
You Might Also Consider
in Breakfast & Brunch, Coffee & Tea, Diners
in Italian, Pizza
Amenities and More
Ask the Community
Yelp users haven’t asked any questions yet about Sal's Pizzeria.
Recommended Reviews
Overall rating
84 reviews
5 stars
4 stars
3 stars
2 stars
1 star
- Oct 22, 202314 check-ins
Always lovin this local Italian mom & pop VERY affordable restaurant! They are SO good to us every time we stop in! It's a great satisfying homestyle meal, or get a slice. Sal's always here manning the ovens himself. Perfection every time!
Tonight I got a personal Sicilian pizza for only $8! Check out my pics for the deets. It's all good here! Thank for reading me & happy healthy yelping!Helpful 8Thanks 2Love this 10Oh no 0 - Jul 2, 2022
I am sitting here at Sal's looking for my prior review and strange though it be, it appears I have never reviewed it. How can that be? Great thin crust AND Sicilian pizza, fresh salads, perfectly cooked pasta, and the best home style parmesans around. Sal cooks it all himself and looks like he was born to be in a kitchen.
5 booths and a few tables, usually filled with families. Many regulars since Sal seems to know them all. A little over a dozen "gourmet" pizzas or build your own. Delicious fresh salads, stuffed bread, paninis, calzones, subs, and "homemade dinners." I've sampled much of the menu and loved it all.
They do seem to do a lot of take out but amazing service. Love this place. Over and over again.Helpful 7Thanks 0Love this 7Oh no 0 - Laura A.Palm Coast, FL0187Sep 13, 2023
I can't speak for the pizza but I can speak for the service and dinners. I had the eggplant parm and my son the chicken parm. They were both delicious and included a house salad and bread. The sauce that was served with the meals was so good. It was nice and fresh tasting. Service was friendly and attentive. I would go back.
Helpful 0Thanks 0Love this 1Oh no 0 - Jennifer M.CT, CT6360161Sep 23, 2023
We stopped in after grocery shopping. The food was really good. We got the veggie pizza and kids pasta. Service was quick and pizza did not disappoint. Cleared my cravings! Pricing overall was not bad either. But it's not much of a sit down place. If you want to eat there it'll be fast and delicious but it's set up for takeout. Nonetheless will be back for sure.
Helpful 0Thanks 0Love this 1Oh no 0 - Frank B.East Windsor, CT075Nov 9, 2023
Sal's is an oasis in the pizza desert known as northern ct.
I've been totally enjoying the pizza at Sal's for over ten years.
If you're jonesing for an authentic NYC pizza, this is the place.
Remember one topping only you know the rules.
I look forward to reading your comments. Now go eat!Helpful 0Thanks 0Love this 0Oh no 0 - Loenard G.CT, CT161May 30, 2022
I ordered Sal's Pizza last evening to satisfy the unstopped hunger I had been receiving.
This pizza certainly satisfied these unruly cravings of mine, but I have some comments and concerns that I wish to address in this review:
1. Over the phone; they told me I can put bacon on "virtually anything", and then preceded to hang up the phone when I requested it be put on the soda I had ordered.
Later, we got the bacon problems sorted, but I was still unsatisfied.
2. when the pizza was finally delivered, I consumed it in record pace, but the meat left more to be desired; it was flaky, overly sweet, and tasted like if someone drowned a baby in olive oil.
My 3rd and final issue with this pizza is that it gave me an aura that I can only describe as despicable.
The pizza was subpar and I felt insulted when consuming it, but all in all I would recommend it to those who want subpar pizza.
3/5
Would recommend.
- Loe GranolaHelpful 0Thanks 0Love this 0Oh no 0 - Mary F.Newington, CT1156May 25, 2023
I love Sal's pizza. The dough is amazing and chewy with a nice golden crust. The texture is thin but not too thin. I love the little bubbles that rise up in the oven and lightly browned. The sauce is my favorite no one else makes a delicious sauce like Sal. I have been going there for years and I used to get the slices for lunch but then I decided I wanted leftovers for dinner or another day. The slices are really a good size and filling but now I just take my time and enjoy eating every single bite. The garlic knots are a good appetizer and the salad can be adjusted for the items you want on your salad. I have had the pizza with roasted red peppers and occasionally other veggies but I really prefer to enjoy the pizza flavor which is the best just as it is delicious. I have also had the cannolis which are very tasty and fresh. Aa
Helpful 0Thanks 0Love this 1Oh no 0 - Mar 13, 2022Updated review
Love sals! Sal has been making pizza and other Italian meals in town for many years. Always great food and always friendly service. His Sicilian pizza is best anywhere in CT. Today we just had 2 grinders; Italian cold cut and chicken parmigiana. Both were excellent! The rolls were amazingly soft and fresh. Lots of lightly fried chicken breast strips with sauce and covered in melted cheese. The Italian cold cut combo with roasted peppers added was delicious as well. Yummy quick meal!
Helpful 2Thanks 0Love this 0Oh no 0Feb 17, 2019Previous reviewSals continues to deliver ( not literally) ! Their Sicilian is THE best in the area and NY style also satisfies. I always order well done for that crispy crust but regardless Sals has excellent pizza AND sells it by the slice!
Aug 31, 2017Previous reviewI continue to like Sal's as my local "go to" pizza shop. Their new personal sized Sicilian pizza is GREAT! Reminds me of NJ Sicilian which I grew up with and love! Also, their "small" salad is larger enough for 2 to share and always super fresh!
Jul 10, 2014Previous reviewIf you want a slice or 2 of pizza and are in the area this place is GREAT. I always like pizza hot from the oven and when you get slices they are often re-heated which makes the crust a little crispier and that much better! Sal's is no exception - while their pizzas to go are slightly above average, their eat-in slices truly rock!
Entrees, grinders and soups also adequate but this is about slices to eat there - AWESOME! - Maggie F.Parkville, Hartford, CT1581Sep 19, 2023
Hands down the BEST New York style pie you'll find! I've been going to Sals for 20 years. Go there for the pizza, try the other menu items, you won't be disappointed- especially when you're treated with kindness and warmth
Helpful 0Thanks 0Love this 0Oh no 0
You Might Also Consider
in Mexican, Vietnamese, Noodles
in Asian Fusion, Chinese