Menu
What's the vibe?
See all 19
Inside
19 photos
See all 8
Outside
8 photos
See all 134
All photos
134 photos
Location & Hours
Saint Augustine, FL 32084
Mon |
| |
|---|---|---|
Tue |
| |
Wed |
| |
Thu |
| |
Fri |
| Open now |
Sat |
| |
Sun |
|
You Might Also Consider
in Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt
in Cocktail Bars, Beer Bar, Pizza
Amenities and More
About the Business
We specialize and are known for our fantastic pizzas using our own recipes for the crust and sauce. With over 30 toppings for your pizzas, and other great options like salads, bread sticks, chicken tenders and wings, and our very own "Pizzalley's Pockets", you're sure to love it here. Closing Hours are based off business flow, they may differ than those listed!
Ask the Community
Yelp users haven’t asked any questions yet about Pizzalley's Dessert Bar.
Recommended Reviews
Overall rating
202 reviews
5 stars
4 stars
3 stars
2 stars
1 star
- Jan 28, 2022
Hard to find but so worth it when you do! Hit em up for their happy hour, live music and half off drinks, win win!
We went there for their HH but as we sat there listening to live music seeing and smelling the food items coming out of the kitchen we decided to skip our original plans and had dinner at Pizzalley's Chianti Room. We weren't disappointed and you won't be either! I ordered the White Pie Pizza and it was phenomenal! My wife ordered the Cheese Tortellini and loved it! Can't wait to try more food items ASAP!
Helpful 19
Thanks 0
Love this 19
Oh no 0 - Apr 18, 2023
Great happy hour! The drinks side of this restaurant is also called Sidecar on St. George. There was limited seating, but we found a spot on a Monday afternoon. The decor is plain with a bunch of mirrors on the walls and one wall is fully brick. Their happy hour runs from 4-6 and features half price desserts and $8 cocktails off their menu. Both of the cocktails I had were tasty and the sips I took of my wife's cocktails were also pretty good. With the A/C, we were a bit chilly, but it definitely could have been worse. Overall, I had a nice time and would recommend Sidecar for happy hour.
Helpful 0Thanks 0Love this 0Oh no 0 
Robert M.St. Augustine, FL18157551Jun 18, 2022Best pizza in Saint Augustine!! We love this place that is not such an obvious find.
The famous "Garbage Can" pizza is so delicious and also great the next day is highly recommended.
They have a full bar and make outstanding Old Fashioned's!
Helpful 0Thanks 0Love this 0Oh no 0
Morgan L.FL, FL754197Jun 24, 2022The Dessert Bar at Pizzalley's just opened a couple of weeks ago in St. Augustine right on historic George street! They have the best boozy desserts and dessert cocktails in St. Aug!
Elliot and Alex gave us the best service and let us sample some delicious goodies! Chef Alex makes everything from scratch in house cookies, biscotti, pecan sandies, cookies, sorbet, and EVERYTHING ELSE!
We tried the Nitro Strawberry Gin Sour with elderflower foam
The Nitro Irish coffee with bourbon whipped cream The Banana Cream Pie with rum whip
And the Gin and Tonic Cheesecake topped with Chef Alex's own gin and tonic jelly which was INSANE
The Intermission is literally brut+sorbet and it was love at first sight Alex whips up the most refreshing homemade orange and cucumber sorbet you'll ever eat!
If you're ever looking for #dessertbeforedinner make sure you stop in for some amazing boozy treats! (absolutely worth the drive but do y'all wanna come open an Orlando location?!)
Helpful 0Thanks 0Love this 0Oh no 0
476121Jan 3, 2022Amazing food and service as always. Pizza is great, dough is perfect, pasta is awesome. The tiramisu was also to die for.
Helpful 1Thanks 0Love this 1Oh no 0
Pilar M.Middleburg, FL512162569Mar 19, 2022Terrible they have bunch of seat empty and put the people to wait for long
Very disappointed because it is a nice pizza place
Helpful 0Thanks 0Love this 0Oh no 0Business owner information
Andrew O.
Mar 26, 2022
Hi Pilar, I'm not sure what day you were here, but our wait times have been pretty short(on saturdays maybe a little longer(maybe up to 45 minutes?) weekdays if at all maybe 15-20 minutes). Unfortunatly we are short staffed as is almost every restaurant around here, so just because we have some open tables does not mean we have enough servers to take more tables right away, or if our kitchen just had a bunch of tickets come in we may have to give them 15 minutes to catch up. Maybe we had just sat a couple large parties and a few other tables and there was only 2 servers on, there's a lot of reasons, but we are not putting people on a wait for no reason i promise you. Have a good day!
- Feb 21, 20211 check-in
Great place to pick up a slice and keep walking when you're going down the center street of Saint Augustine. If you want to sit there are a few seats in the front and a full-service restaurant in the back. It's nice to be able to just simply get a single slice and not have to worry about walking around with entire pie. Overall good pizza with plenty of toppings. Dog friendly as well.
Helpful 24Thanks 0Love this 21Oh no 0Business owner information
Andrew O.
Mar 27, 2021
Glad you enjoyed our pizza John! Stop in anytime :)
- Feb 3, 2020
This was conveniently located behind the Bayfront Hilton. There was a wait I in Saturday evening but it was worth it.
We ordered simply salads and pizza. They were delivered quick and Brian our waiter did an excellent job.
The limoncello lemonade was really yummy.
Would highly recommend to anyone visiting the St Augustine area.
Helpful 1Thanks 0Love this 0Oh no 0 
88078Nov 14, 2020We walked several blocks carrying a baby, after fighting for parking, to order pizza from them. Google had their hours posted until 1:30am. We were met at the door by an employee who informed us that since covid they had shortened their hours. We are 8 months into all of us dealing with Covid. There is no reason to not have ensured your hours are correct online. Disappointed that we wasted our time.
Update:They have since updated their hours with Google (although they are claiming in response that it was already posted correctly.) Two of us double checked it after we were turned away, and we chose this place because their closing time was posted as 1:30am. Closing hours based on volume in my opinion isn't a very good way to earn business. We still found another option that night but were pissed that we wasted our time trying to eat here.Helpful 0Thanks 0Love this 1Oh no 0Business owner information
Andrew O.
Nov 19, 2020
Hi Stephanie, I'm not sure who you talked to. We have never had set closing hours. Google does not have Pizzalleys or Chianti Room's hours listed to 1:30 either(im not sure where you saw that). Unfortunatly google has no option to close based on volume so you must pick a time, which ours is set between 8:30 and 11 depending on weekday or weekend. There is also an alert right below the hours listed on google stating "Hours of service may differ". Be aware that the majority of businesses downtown also close based off volume as well for future reference.
You Might Also Consider
in Southern, Cocktail Bars, Seafood
in Pizza
