Pinky Shrimp's Seafood Co

Very good. Have been taking out from Pinky's for over 20 years. Take out only. Great seafood.

Vibes: beachy seafood market with bench tables out front

Tasting notes:
- Scallops (small): sweet, tender bite; perfectly broiled with just the lightest of caramelization; very pleasantly surprised at the number and size
- Crispy clam strips (large): savory and incredibly addicting; coating is on the thicker, breadier side
- Caribbean shrimp (12 pc): absolutely loved the size of each shrimp - took a few bites to finish; great coating-to-meat ratio; one of the most crunchy coconut shrimp I've ever had; the dipping sauce is very sweet, reminiscent of citrus marmalade, very unique

Other thoughts:
- Love the variety of the menu and portion options
- Time from order to pick-up was 10-15 minutes
- The above meal was very satisfying for two hungry adults
- Staff told us the side of cole slaw were small ahead of time so we ordered one for each of us. They came in little condiment cups so we were grateful for the headsup.

Impression: my absolute favorite restaurant on LBI, is on my must-visit list for first-time visitors to LBI and seafood lovers!

Classic LBI vibe. Nothing like a nice seafood snack/ meal after the beach or pool time.
The cape codder is a more than generous portion and priced on point.

The fries are seriously the best I have ever had. The cod is breaded to perfection.

I enjoyed 12 clams on the half shell.they were so fresh and delish.

You can order ahead for pick up or eat outside at the tables in the parking lot.

Do not miss the chance to try Pinkys. Wish they were open year round.

We ordered takeout from pinky's this past weekend and it did not disappoint! We placed an order for 8 people and it was ready in 45 minutes for pickup. We all ordered seafood dishes and they all traveled well and were extremely fresh. I personally got the mighty mussels and they have you tons of them! I ended up sharing with everyone since I couldn't finish the dish myself. Their linguine and sauce were so tasty as well! Everyone enjoyed their dinners from Pinky's and the prices were very reasonable also! Unfortunately I didn't take any pictures of our food, but it was outstanding and we will be back soon!

Pinky's is a great spot for some fresh seafood.

After looking over their menu online, my boyfriend and I ordered two clam chowders - both great, a lobster salad roll and the seafood combo.

The only complaint I have is that everything was really under seasoned. All in all, that's not the worst thing, I'd rather add a little salt myself then have it be unbearably over salted. So that's what we did, just added a little seasoning to everything.

The baked potatoes as sides were both great too. The chowders had a ton of clam meat as well. My lobster salad roll was piled high with fresh meat. It was actually enough for two meals. My boyfriends platter was also really good.

This place is definitely just for pick up so call ahead and they'll give you a ring when everything is ready. The staff was definitely working hard too, they're a busy busy spot.

Fresh, great seafood! Amazing fish market and dinner spot! We had lunch there after the beach, low
Key and casual. It was a bit pricey, keep that in mind when you look at the menu as there are not prices listed. Would go for a quick meal or for take out. Seating is only a few tables outside as it is a fish market

Nice market and restaurant in LBI. Really enjoyed the steamers (little necks), coconut shrimp, clams casino and broiled scallops.

Order inside, grab a table, get called when ready! Super nice staff. Super efficient. Plenty of parking.

Good tunes playing outside as well.

Place is great. Super clean, convenient and affordable. Would recommend to anyone in the island craving seafood without having to sit down and spend $200.

Haven't had the food yet but to walk into a place without guidance or online ordering and for them to say it'll be 1 to 1.5 hours for your dinner to be ready ....is utterly preposterous. Don't care how busy it is ...that's not a business. Make it clear that food needs to be ordered hours in advance. What are people supposed to do ?!? Wait outside for 2 hours ? Drive home ? What's the plan here guys?!? Will come back and change the rating if the food is worth this insanity ...but I can't imagine any food is....

Solid seafood choices. Fast pickups or love eating outside on the picnic tables. An LBI Classic