Mary's Mountain Cookies - Old Town Fort Collins

Right when walking in, it is a smaller place but the service is def fast if you know what you want. They serve you first and then you pay. Everyone was very friendly and helped us when needed. The space was also clean and very homey to be in!

Salted Caramel 5/5 -- basically snickerdoodle with glaze on top. It was soooo good!
M&M cookie 3/5 -- this was alright. It was soft and good but wouldn't get it again
Brownie 4/5 -- super moist and sweet. Loved it!

They also have items that were refrigerated such as cookie dough and drinks!

An old favorite that we visit anytime we are in town. The buy 6 get 2 free deal is perfect for friends and gatherings. Love the old classics dirty panda and salt mine, and trying their new flavors.

The best cookie place I've ever been too!

If you are a cookie fan then you can't miss Mary's Mountain Cookies ! They're conveniently located along with all the other shops in Old Town, so you can grab a cookie to walk around with or finish up your exploring with some cookies to go.

The space isn't too big, but there are a few seats by the window. Plus the smell of fresh cookies is enough to keep you in there for a bit!
There's plenty of free parking in the area.

They have a wide variety of cookie options which are all delicious ! There's classic flavors and unique ones - there's even cookie sandwiches.

You can also buy a bucket of cookie dough if your in the mood to make some yourself at home.

Plus the service is great! Everyone who works there is extremely nice and ready to give you some cookie recommendations

Tantalizing array of huge soft cookies, including separately wrapped gluten-free ones, as well as ice cream to make sandwiches and the ability to custom order humungous ones. It made a great afternoon treat and we left with some for later as well.

If you don't eat them right away, be sure to be careful with them since they don't travel well because they are so amazingly soft.

The staff was very friendly on the afternoon that we arrived and we had a blast chatting with them while we decided what to get.

COWW cookies was recommended by the 2 ladies working there and that cookie was super good. And she warmed it up so it was great!

Best cookies ever!! Since they can be sealed, they have even gone to my family overseas as a gift! Also the staff is always very friendly and helpful!

We love Mary's Mtn Cookies. We live in GA, but our son lives in Fort Collins, and every time we come to town, we have to get cookies from there. We've tried a lot of them, but I especially recommend the Smores and the Trash Panda cookie. Their brownies are also good.

I am all about the ooey gooey soft baked cookies and this place delivered. I love anything salted caramel these days whether it's a cookie, coffee, ice cream, cup cake, etc so my decision was easy! My son got the snickerdoodle chocolate chip, which would have been my second choice.

Very reasonably priced for the size of them. Lots of flavors to choose from. They even have keto cookies and gluten free.

I might need to take a dozen home!!

Ordered a pumpkin chocolate chip cookie and it was raw in the middle went to exchange it, and the girl rolled her eyes at me two times

They have many, many unique cookie flavors. The cookies are also huge, probably 2-4 serving sizes per cookie. We ordered 4 different kinds and were satisfied with all. We were visiting on a week long trip and these held up well in their packaging so we were able to enjoy throughout our trip. Only taking one star away as the there were MANY flies in the establishment and nothing to keep them out of the cookie display (we specifically didn't order cookies we saw flies land and chill on). The service was friendly if slightly impatient. They also sell beverages (like milk cuz ya can't have cookies without milk!) and some business swag like t shirts and we even purchased those as souviners.