Tommy's Pizza

Truly, the best pizza we have had in years! We are so tired of bad pizza, commercial pizza. those huge rounds of mediocre ingredients on an awful crust. Now for Tommy's Pizza: simply the best. As soon as we saw it, we knew it was grand. Here was a pizza with a beautiful sense of tomatoes and cheese and a perfect crust, both crunchy and charred. It is exactly the way a pizza should taste. It is genuine pizza. We are so happy Tommy's is back in town! Welcome to the neighborhood. Oh, yes, they do accept credit cards.

It seems all the reviews are for the previous owner who has passed away. I just tried the newly opened pizza restaurant and was pleasantly impressed with the quality and service. Reasonable cost and tasty good size pizza. Will return in the future.

RIP George, you made a damn good pie. Lived in Sharpsburg for 22 years, and you never failed. Thanks for the fine pie.
Miss your fine phone ediquitte....
"Hello Tommy's" its our inside family joke.

Don't pass this place up. We were riding the MABDR and we stopped in and had a great sub sandwich. The pizza looked great too. We stumbled upon it but it is well worth planning a stop.

In Shepherdstown for an annual Guy's weekend 2019. Sunday night, last night and looking for a last meal that was going to be enjoyable and non nutritional focused! PIZZA !! We all agreed this was our goal. Thanks to a very few reviews Tommy's came up. We had a short walk to the place and it didn't disappoint at all. FRESH BAKED PIZZA according to our specifications and it was delicious. We also ordered wings - buffalo style- and they were 8/10. Deliciousness in meatiness and -2 in texture and lack of crispness ( personal preference?). I think this place deserves a respect of durability- if this place can operate for 40 years, we need to respect they are doing it right by their customers whether or not the casual guest rates it one way or the other.

I always loved this restaurant. Best pizza around. I'll miss their pizzas. Fine gentleman.

I moved to town a couple of weeks ago and one of the first things I did was try to find a good pizza place. Maybe I was just lucky, but Tommy's was the first one I tried, and I've ordered from them 3 or 4 times already.

The guy on the phone is a man of few words, but that suits me just fine. The pizza is great. I think that most pizza places get by with tasteless crust and bland cheese... not Tommy's. Tommy's crust has a great flavor and the cheese is great.

Also, sausage is my topping of choice. So many times, sausage is not a good topping on the East Coast. Most places tend to use the sliced sausage instead of the crumbled sausage. Tommy's uses crumbled sausage that has a great flavor. I don't know if they make it in house, but it tastes great. I will definitely continue to come back.

The best pizza in Shepherdstown. Always quick, always delicious. Highly recommend!! The Baked Sausage Pizza with all the seasoning and crunchy, crispy crust--soooo good.

On October 29th, 2019 my wife and I were passing through from Ohio. We walked into the place at about 7pm. There was an older gray haired man and a younger woman behind the counter. Not one customer in the place. Wife says to the older man...Hello, how are you today? He looks at her and looks at me and then goes back to work. The woman kept her back turned. We stood there for a few minutes and then left.

Not sure what the deal was or why he couldn't say hi but I'd not recommend the place when they can't even acknowledge a customer.

If I could give less than a star I would! Me and my mother stopped by near closing time hoping to grab a slice or 2 of pizza. We walked inside and the owner right away seemed very aggressive. We were very polite and asked if he had any left over pizzas from the day or something to that degree. He looked at us and proceeded to ignore us and go back to work. My mother (being very frustrated) decided to run to the rest room and allow me to talk with the older man. As soon as she started walking towards the restroom he began to approach her in an aggressive manner and started yelling at her saying only paying customers were allowed to use it. My mother ( thank god she isn't shy ) gave him a piece of her mind and we proceeded to leave. Aside from the roach infested interior and moldy yellow walls, we thought to give this small town pizzeria a shot. Not a chance in hell you will catch me anywhere near this place after our experience. Owner should be shutdown if he can't provide a clean restaurant or even the slightest bit of human kindness. Also I am mixed ethnicity's so it could have been a racial thing or the owner is just bonkers!!!! Please I beg of you don't go here, there is many cool local bars in the town that serve good pizza and drinks!