Menu
Review Highlights
“In short, the pizza was good, FF were very crispy, and we were happy with the cheesesteak that we split.” in 3 reviews
$11.99 Cheesesteak“The only downside to this place is that they don't have fountain soda.” in 2 reviews
“I would sooner put mayonnaise in my coffee than on an Italian Cold Cut Sub, but there it was, unasked for.” in 2 reviews
You Might Also Consider
in New American, Breakfast & Brunch, Tapas/small Plates
in Delis, Gas Stations
Amenities and More
Ask the Community
Yelp users haven’t asked any questions yet about Tim's Pizza & Subs.
Recommended Reviews
Overall rating
33 reviews
5 stars
4 stars
3 stars
2 stars
1 star
- Barry B.MD, MD045Jan 15, 2024
My daughter Maude went here and asked for pizza. Apparently that's what they sell here cause she got. And boyyyy did she get it. She basically is a pizza now, send help. We are on the corner of beaglin park drive and mt hermon road. Spacious seating too.
Helpful 0Thanks 0Love this 0Oh no 0 - Kelly W.Salisbury, MD0214Apr 2, 2024
My fault. When I walked into the restaurant during what should be rush hour and I found it empty, that should have been a clue. I just wanted a good piece of pizza. THIS is not the place!
Helpful 0Thanks 0Love this 0Oh no 0 - Eric O.Selbyville, DE281667Jun 4, 2023
Shopping at Ollie's and needed a quick lunch. Found this little hole in the wall type of place. Boy was this a great decision. The place was empty and we sat right down. The lady working was so sweet and pleasant. The food came quick and was pretty big portions. One of the best cheesesteaks I've had. The roll was so fresh and it was delicious. Service was great. The only downside to this place is that they don't have fountain soda. Everything is cans or bottles. I'm stopping here again every time I'm in the area. Even took a slice to strawberry cheesecake home. Huge slice and was amazing!.
Helpful 0Thanks 0Love this 0Oh no 0 - Anna K.Evansville, IN032Jun 29, 2023
Overpriced $17.99 for a small overcooked dry pizza that isn't edible by any means. The place was empty. Not a single customer there....should have been my first clue. The woman at the counter is extremely rude. Never again.
Helpful 0Thanks 0Love this 0Oh no 0 - James S.MD, MD01Feb 10, 2023
In short, the pizza was good, FF were very crispy, and we were happy with the cheesesteak that we split. We will stop by again next time we are in the area.
Helpful 0Thanks 0Love this 0Oh no 0 - C. S.Tampa, FL371126Aug 15, 2019
Basing my review solely off my quick in/out experience. Got two slices of pizza. They were pleasant and accommodating immediately. Place is clean, dessert box looked tempting with those beautiful slices of cheesecake, but I kept focus on my slices of pizza instead. I'm not a local, only here for the week. But I could see myself going back if I did live here. I'd at least give this place a try.
Helpful 1Thanks 0Love this 1Oh no 0 - Scott B.Dover, DE47523Sep 22, 2017
Attention Yelp friends...My wife & I have literally paid for $Thousands of dollars of food from Tim's Pizza & Subs next to Food Lion on the East side of Salisbury @244 Tilghman Rd....a few weeks ago we ordered cheese steak subs, toasted, extra meet, extra cheese, lettuce, raw onion, tomato, & mayo...after receiving the order, the roll was soggy, no extra cheese, barely any raw onion and a few strands of soggy lettuce...So Kelly called to let them know we were unhappy and this was our 1st complaint in nearly 7 years. The lady owner, that would not get on the phone said we were liars & would not replace our order....Boom...shocked as all get out!!...
So fast forward to tonight...I reached out to see if i could work things out by placing a pizza order & see if they would compensate something, anything...to my surprise, The owner, of course not willing to get on the phone ...said no way, we don't want your business because she still doesn't believe us & she saw a bad re iew on Yelp that she didn't appreciate...well...your choice...i personally stand behind any & all of Skylark Management's workmanship...I appreciate when a customer reaches out if they have a problem & 9 out of 10 times, i catch any problems before my customers even know there is a problem...
In conclusion, i am asking whoever wants to stand behind us, to boycott this place...We as customers deserve better...#disgruntledcustomerHelpful 3Thanks 0Love this 2Oh no 0 - Kelly B.Salisbury, MD0442Sep 2, 2017
We order from Tim's on a regular basis. The last two times we have ordered, subs that we requested to be toasted were not toasted. Tonight we ordered again. I got a Meatzaboli which was actually good. My husband got a cheese steak sub with lettuce, tomato, mayonaise and raw onion, toasted. Again, the sub was not toasted, there was barely any lettuce, one tomato and no mayonaise. I never call and complain but after three orders were incorrect, I thought the owner should know. We like Tim's and re8commend it a lot. Instead of making the order right, the owner wanted to argue. Nope! Not happening. You do not treat loyal customers that way. We will find a new place to eat!
Helpful 2Thanks 0Love this 2Oh no 0 - Rachel H.Laguna Beach, CA0137Jul 27, 2019
Stopped on a whim. So happy we did. Kind waitress. Quick service. Fresh yummy onion rings, calzone and pizza. Would definitely go again.
Helpful 0Thanks 0Love this 0Oh no 0 - Geoffrey E.Salisbury, MD1575Mar 16, 2019
Ordered over the phone, and went to pick it up. From order time to receiving my food it took 42 minutes. All I ordered was 12 wings and fries. The wings were extremely overcooked, dry and burnt.
Helpful 0Thanks 0Love this 0Oh no 0
You Might Also Consider
in Italian
in New American, Sandwiches, Delis