Review Highlights
“There's a lot of great places to see in the Village, but you don't want to miss the Four-Faced Liar!” in 20 reviews
“I looked up good Guinness bars in the West Village on Google and this place popped up and it 100% delivered.” in 30 reviews
“.let's just say she's been living in the Village before I was even born!(which was in the 60's)..say hello to her.” in 4 reviews
Location & Hours
You Might Also Consider
in Seafood, New American, Burgers
in Lounges, Wine Bars, American
Amenities and More
Ask the Community
Yelp users haven’t asked any questions yet about The Four-Faced Liar.
Recommended Reviews
Overall rating
233 reviews
5 stars
4 stars
3 stars
2 stars
1 star
- Jan 21, 2023
A great dive bar in the WV area. It's cozy And comfortable and offers multiple seating options. Great for both groups and smaller parties.
Random thing to note, I love how many bag/coat hooks they had scattered throughout the bar. It's the little things that really make a difference.
Normally at a dive I'd order a beer but they had a full bar so me and my date both got standard cocktails and they were good!
I'd definitely come back here in the future.
5/5Helpful 2Thanks 0Love this 3Oh no 0 - 33151405Mar 20, 2023
Nice and a cozy bar. Caught this place while bar hopping on St. Patrick's. It's a pretty decent space with 8 to 12 tables and a bar.
As usual crowded on St Patrick's but we had a reservation to avoid the huge wait. Ordered some beers and an Irish Coffee (contains Whiskey) for the table. Ended up ordering the Irish Coffee since there weren't cocktails available.
On the whole, it was a good experience. Loved the music too.Helpful 0Thanks 0Love this 1Oh no 1 - Aug 23, 2023Updated review
The best place for a Guiesness and my own favorite is the Lynchburg lemonade. Much love to staff, Mikey, Jason, Marko, Jimmy, John, as well as the owner Connor, always showing me genuine love for so many years.
Helpful 0Thanks 0Love this 0Oh no 0Mar 7, 2023Previous reviewGood people, prices and drinks. A place where people care, especially if you get to know the regulars and the bartenders. They are always helpful, friendly, and cordial.
This past weekend at the Four Faced liar was great and packed with some great people I've met.
Always a good and relaxing time at the four faced liar. The weekend can tend to be packed, so an early arrival is suggested. - Rachel M.Harlem, New York, NY03Feb 10, 2024
I freakin LOVE this bar. It's my go-to with friends. It's so fun, and we always stop here for at least one on a night out. We're known to shoot a few tequila shots back here. ;) cheers!
Helpful 0Thanks 0Love this 0Oh no 0 - 14567696Mar 11, 2023
It was a very dark bar and the bathrooms were really dirty. Lot of seating available but was not my favorite bar. Not rushing to go back unfortunately.
Helpful 0Thanks 0Love this 0Oh no 0 - Megan M.New York, NY1748130Feb 28, 2022
Like all basic white women I studied abroad in college. In NYC I've never found a pub that had the warmth and a good enough Guinness to make me want to consume carbs...I'm sorry SVW I know I shouldn't but it taste just like Ireland here.
A nice bloke named Gav took me here. We talked rugby and "crushed pints" it was a good night. I really wish he had family money cause it could have worked. Sadly he didn't fit the bill, but I keep coming back to this placeHelpful 1Thanks 0Love this 11Oh no 1 - Maria M.Omaha, NE41213Feb 12, 2023
Great place , not uptight or classy seems like a very cool grunge/rock type atmosphere. Beers were good. The vibe is dive dark. Got pretty toasty and the music was rockin. I'm not sure about the restroom situation, they are in a very strange location. Will be back next time
Helpful 0Thanks 0Love this 0Oh no 0 - Selina L.Indianapolis, IN022Sep 22, 2023
The most unfriendly server. Three of our friends ordered multiple drinks at the bar, and the two of us felt cold sitting inside so we moved outside to sit only for 10 minutes. The server came out and told us we cannot sit here because this is for customers only but there are so many empty chairs and table, and we also ordered at least four drinks! Never coming back again!
Helpful 0Thanks 1Love this 0Oh no 1 - Karina L.Bay Ridge, Brooklyn, NY05Aug 7, 2023
Good drinks and very reasonably priced for the city. After 6pm on week days, place does become more populated with khaki wearing popped collared pink polo-ed finance bros/interns in the summer
Helpful 0Thanks 1Love this 0Oh no 0 - Joey L.New York, NY1211Nov 11, 2021
Went there with my girlfriend and asked to be seated. The waiter seated us outside. So far, so good. As it was cold out and we didn't want to go inside during covid, my girlfriend asked if the heater could be turned on. Waiter's reply: you can do it yourself. Okay, fine. Weird but fine. Here's what happened next:
Waiter: what do you want?
Me: what do you have on draft?
Waiter: what are you looking for?
Girlfriend: ... alcohol...
Waiter lists off eight or so beers
Me: I'll take two Guinnesses and two water
Girlfriend: oh, we can't get the heater to work, could you help?
Waiter: (sighs -- becoming angry) why don't you guys just sit inside?
Brings back our drinks; slams them down.
Waiter: that'll be 16 bucks
He was so rude that we didn't even want to take a sip. My girlfriend at that point said "no, no thanks. We won't be drinking here." He angrily took the drinks back and said "okay, fine, whatever." This guy is a total nutcase. Avoid this place and the short Latino looking guy at all costs.Helpful 1Thanks 1Love this 2Oh no 0
You Might Also Consider
in Whiskey Bars, New American, Gastropubs
in Pubs