Review Highlights
“Cakes, pastries, donuts, desserts, cookies, whatever you are craving or looking for, Sweet Mags can do it.” in 9 reviews
“The cinnamon rolls are perfection and everything else is so good that I try at least one new item each visit.” in 23 reviews
“This sweet little bakery located right next to Lisa's Radial Cafe is my absolute favorite place to go for sweet treats.” in 10 reviews
People also searched for
Location & Hours
Other Desserts Nearby
in Desserts, Bakeries, Cupcakes
in Pizza, Desserts, Italian
Amenities and More
About the Business
Business owner information
Katina T.
Located in Omaha's historic Joslyn Castle neighborhood, Sweet Magnolias Bake Shop is a boutique bakery specializing in perfectly crafted, melt-in-your-mouth confections. We don't just bake desserts. We pour our hearts into them. From our buttery, soft cinnamon rolls to our signature Brown Sugar Cardamom cake, each recipe is expertly developed to both inspire the palate and evoke a sense of delicious nostalgia - to strike a perfect balance between imaginative and timeless. Most importantly, we use from-scratch ingredients and make every item by hand in our little kitchen, so you can feel good knowing exactly where and who your food comes from.
Ask the Community
Yelp users haven’t asked any questions yet about Sweet Magnolias Bake Shop.
Recommended Reviews
Overall rating
180 reviews
5 stars
4 stars
3 stars
2 stars
1 star
- May 15, 2024
Really stumbled upon this place when we were waiting for our reservation next door at Lisa's Radial Cafe. Noticed a small crowd of people in line for this bakery and figured may as well join on in while we're here. Definitely worth stopping by and the wait!
Key Lime Pie Bar - 5/5 Has the perfect amount of tart and sweetness
Peanut Butter Crunch Bar - 5/5 - If you love peanut butter and chocolate then this one is a must!
Poptart - 5/5 Their poptart is fantastic and tastes just like the real thing but without all the crap that comes with the prepackaged on the shelf stuff
Thahini Butterscotch - 2.5/5 - this flavor was a little off for me and not sure I really loved the combination. Will need to pass on this next time
Looking for a great bakery then come by Sweet Magnolias Bake Shop!Helpful 0Thanks 0Love this 1Oh no 0 - 342201472May 11, 20241 check-in
Sweet Mag's makes an AMAZING chocolate chip cookie. For moments after my first bite I was transported to heaven. It was cooked to absolutely perfection and still warm when I ordered it. My husband ordered a lemon bar and was similarly blown away. I unfortunately didn't get any photos of the treats because I ate them too fast. The staff was also super friendly. I unfortunately don't live in Omaha and was just there for a quick visit but if I'm ever back you can count on me to visit Sweet Mag's again!
Helpful 0Thanks 0Love this 0Oh no 0 - May 4, 2024
Small but awesome bakery. Everything tasted great. Service was fast, friendly, and efficient. We bought cinnamon rolls, brownies, and bars. I would gain 30 pounds if I lived nearby. The hours are somewhat limited and there is not a lot of parking close by.
Helpful 0Thanks 0Love this 0Oh no 0 - Cheryl W.Queens, Queens, NY851433Apr 28, 2024
This location is smaller than the Millwork one, but still has a lot of goods. It's located right next to Lisa's Radial Cafe and Amateur Coffee which is really convenient. There is lots of street parking and a small parking lot across the street. The employee who helped us pick our items was very friendly. I went mostly for the cardamom twist which they only offer on Tuesday, Thursday, and Saturday, and it was soooo good. It's my favorite thing from their shop. I look forward to when I can get it again!
Helpful 0Thanks 0Love this 0Oh no 0 - 424822378Sep 11, 2023
Stopping in for some goodies from Sweet Magnolias - Midtown.
OK, I'm hooked!
Having attended the North downtown arts fair over Labor Day, I enjoyed the Sweet Magnolia shop at Millwork and have been back twice already this past week! Went over there on Sunday and did not realize that they were not open - yikes. Checking the hours I found out that their midtown location is open on Sundays, and we quickly drove over there to get our cookie fix!
Located just south of Cumming Street, it is next-door to Lisa's Radial Cafe. Sunday mornings street parking can be a little tight with restaurant brunch and neighborhood church traffic so plan accordingly.
The shop is small, but has plenty of room for a wonderful selection of goodies. Voted the best of Omaha for a number of years in a row and I now know why. This is a must stop for anyone looking for a different type of treat that is a little more on the healthier side.
Like most bakeries, they start early and close early and can sell out, so check hours and if you're really looking for something special get there early!
This is a must stop along with their Millwork location. Check hours to ensure that you understand what days of the week they're open. The shop is focused on having space for goodies so this is a take away location only.Helpful 0Thanks 0Love this 1Oh no 0 - Oct 25, 2023
Stopped in because I had heard that this little place was good.
As I sit at the cafe beside it. (Because they didn't have coffee) Box on the table-
I'm thinking about the experience I had -
I walked in the door no one acknowledged or even looked up at me. Look around. Mind you this place is tiny so it's not like you don't know I'm there ...
One of the 3 girls that had just got off of her phone comes over. Doesn't say anything just stands there -
I ask what the scones are and as she speed races through it....
I ask her to repeat a few- and ask for a couple bars as well.
Pay-
Get that look like I should tip her. $20 because she gave me the best service of my life. Not!
I haven't tried there stuff. Given that lack of service and graciousness
I think I might just give this &30 box of stuff to the homeless manHelpful 0Thanks 0Love this 0Oh no 0Business owner information
Katina T.
Oct 25, 2023
Hi Tisha - sorry to hear you were disappointed in the service you received! I hope you enjoy your pastries!
- 52733Apr 6, 2024Updated review
Another stop on my Omaha tour for my parents and as always, didn't disappoint. The honey lavender cookie with lavender frosting was the group favorite, but we also really enjoyed the oatmeal cookie sandwich and cinnamon sugar donut. Key lime pie bar was a little too sour for us, but everything else was delicious! Bakers immediately greeted us and were very patient while we deliberated what to order
Helpful 0Thanks 0Love this 0Oh no 0Mar 23, 2024Previous reviewMy favorite bakery in Omaha! I've been twice now and also gotten their donuts from Amateur coffee. I love all the options that can pretty much accommodate any dietary restriction. My absolute favorite is the ginger cardamom cookie available in the winter season but they always have something delicious despite the season. Most recently tried the honey lavender cookie sandwich and I will be back for it. Their cookies are more crunchy with a softer inside, which I personally enjoy but know not everyone will. I've tried the bars a couple times and a little too rich for me but I know many love them.
The employees are always sweet and patient with my indecisive self trying to choose what to try this time. The shop is small but service is still quick. - Melinda P.Omaha, NE052Apr 19, 2024
We ordered a birthday cake, it was dry and frosting tasted like butter only.
Service was unfriendly. Very disappointed based on such great reviewsHelpful 0Thanks 0Love this 0Oh no 0Business owner information
Katina T.
Apr 19, 2024
Hi Melinda - sorry to hear you didn’t enjoy your cake. I don’t see an order under your name, but would appreciate an email with more information about the cake that was ordered. We pride ourselves on delicious products, as well as great customer service. It’s surprising to hear you felt service was unfriendly. It would be helpful if you could include details about why you felt this way in your email. You can email us at the same email address used to order the cake!
We do use real butter, and no shortening, in our buttercream frosting, so we think being able to taste the butter is a good thing! We understand if this isn’t your preference! - Apr 3, 2023
Sweet mags is a classic Omaha bake shop that never disappoints. They have a variety of baked goods and every one that I've tried has not disappointed. The oatmeal cream pies are my absolute favorite. The cookies are perfectly baked and the cream is mouthwatering! The cheese cake bar and the cinnamon roll was also delicious.
It's a small bakery with no seating really but is a convenient spot to pick up orders to go. I know that even if my favorites are sold out here, I'll be able to find something delicious. I'll continue to return never time my sweet tooth acts up!Helpful 0Thanks 0Love this 0Oh no 0
Other Desserts Nearby
in Desserts
in Bakeries, Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt, Desserts