Rico's Pizza New York Style

I made a visit to the Corning Museum of Glass. After going to the museum, my family and I went to Rico's for some NY style pizza. Let me say everyone besides me gave this place 5 stars. The pizza was good, nice thin crispy crust, grease dripping from it. I ate the ends like you do with NY style pizza.

But for me to give a place 5 stars, the place has to be special. To me there wasn't anything special about the pizza. It was what I expected good NY pizza to be like. 4 stars.

We did a takeout order of two gluten free pizzas and wings. Not sure if he was the owner but he checked our pizzas and had them cook a bit longer because the gf crusts don't brown the same. I appreciated their extra check! We had medium and garlic Parmesan wings - love that they weren't greasy. I got the white garden pizza - tons of garlic that I love. Will definitely order from them again!

Very skimpy Italian sub. The meats were few and cut so thinly you could read a newspaper through them. Only a few diced tomatoes. No slices of tomato. I asked for extra onions which had a Fifty cent upcharge and there were only maybe a few additional slivers added. Subway and Wegman's offer a much better product and value. The sub was mostly bread.

My partner and I ordered delivery and it was 20 minutes late. The food didn't look very appealing so we didn't have high expectations. The crust was very doughy and the garlic bread was drenched in butter to the point it was soggy but that wasn't the worst of it. My partner was eating her cannoli only to discover a small piece of plastic cooked inside of it and was horrified. The food is not worth the price at all and I'm assuming they don't prep their food with caution.

Food takes so long to prepare but overall not to bad the menu can be a bit overwhelming. It's very clean and organized. And the wait is worth it

After reading a few reviews and a note that was left at the Air B&B we decided to give it a try. It was not good. We ordered two small pizzas and one came out cold. They did not have good flavor especially for the cost. It seemed like the person taking our a order was annoyed with the fact that we walked in at 5:45pm even though their hours said until 9pm. Would give it zero stars if that were an option.

Heck yeah. Former Corning residents ask me to bring a Rico's when I go to visit!

If you're looking for authentic thin New York style pizza, crispy but nicely topped, this will fit the bill.

Nice that the owner is very engaged too. He makes our day!

Still the best pizza in Corning. We have them deliver nearly every week. Great selection of pizzas, and their delivery is reliable and almost always earlier than expected.

Pizza is decent but avoid salads and sandwiches. A whole eggplant parm for $13... and barely any eggplant and cheese. Very disappointed.

Pizza was very good. Pepperoni was thick. We were there on Sunday afternoon (April 24). The young lady that took our order also made the pizza. She did a good job she helped her co worker who seemed to be new. The store was clean and customer service was good. When we are Corning next time, we will come back to this spot.