Portobello's Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria

Simply the best New York pizza place in our region - this coming from a pizza bigot. Growing up in Brooklyn and Queens, having sampled most local pizza places, nothing comes close.

The bread/crust is so very good and the meals (veal parmigiana, sausage, etc...) is wonderful. The service is outstanding and the price is right.

On top - it is BYOB!!!

Ordered take out from here and everything was phenomenal! I got the zuppa di vongole and a steak Stromboli. Both were 10/10. I will most definitely be returning and bringing my family here when they're in town!

I've been here a half dozen times. I've gotten the calzone each time. Eat half, take half home and eat it next day as leftovers. It's huge. It's delicious. It's STUFFED with toppings.
Their speed of service could be better but overall, great spot tucked away in Harrison.

It's been years since I've been here & I can't exactly remember what I had, while the meal wasn't terrible...it was very wet. As in it was packed in a puddle of water wet. I've never ordered any Italian dish that(outside of soup at Olive Garden)that was slposhy wet mesh. I keep saying I may give them another try, I just haven't been there again.

Great to have a local pizzeria in the area but it's overpriced. The staff is adequate but not friendly and dining room old/dusty. Meat-stuffed pizza is pretty good but too greasy. I stopped going when I ordered (w/o looking at price) 12 small garlic knots for $10.
The dough/crust is good when fresh but tastes frozen sometimes.

Pizza is good... but heavily overpriced not worth it will not be coming here often. Staff is very nice and friendly

Been many times and they provide very good food and plenty of it. Surprised by the large size you get when ordering a small pizza. Come hungry my friends.

We got lunch to go. It was covered in grease and looked repugnant. The smell of the chicken alone made us queasy. The cheese ravioli was tasteless. I would have rather eaten cold Chef Boyardee from a can.

This is a great little Italian restaurant. They serve everything from pizza to pasta dishes. The service is fantastic and friendly. If you try it once you'll be back because everything is good Lobster Ravioli

Service was mediocre but the food was worth it! I would definitely come back! The portobello pizza was amazing!