Papa's Pizzeria and Italian Cuisine

Papa's is a small spot in a strip mall off Green St. It is currently carry out or delivery only. The ordering process online is very easy and they bring food out to your car. They have a larger menu than I'd expected including pizzas, calzones, and specialty pasta dishes.
We went with the traditional spaghetti & meatballs which had a good flavor and we enjoyed the meatballs. There were 2 of good size. You can order more online. We also had the tutti mare which was ok. Nice shrimp, mini scallops and mussels. It was actually better the 2nd day. Pasta dishes come with garlic bread which was pretty basic. We did enjoy the tiramisu which was large enough to share. Overall we would try it again. Maybe the pizzas next.

Updating my review, we used to go here all the time and it's literally been years and still the dining area is closed. A pizza by the slice that you have to order and pick up is ridiculous and it doesn't take years to find staff.

We were craving Italian and did a quick Yelp search and landed on Papa's! Everything we ok. The food was ok, it wasn't bad, but also wasn't great.

I was hoping the Pasta Primavera would be on the lighter side, but it's a pretty heavy dish. But the salad was nice and fresh and could happily be a full meal if you're craving something lighter.

The ordering and carry out process was super smooth and efficient.

Food is always great! Curbside pickup is all that is available though. This place never disappoints when I'm in Brownsburg!

Awesome pasta that's made to order, well seasoned, generous portions and excellent pricing.

Tutto mare - one of our favorites! Excellent flavor and lots of seafood included. It is perfectly seasoned. Love it.

Meatball Pomodoro - chopped meatballs pasta. Bigger portion than the spaghetti and meatballs. First time I had it was a little salty for my taste. I plan to try it again and ask for less salt.

Spaghetti and meatballs - smaller portions than their specialty pastas but still a ton of food for just $8! That's less than many fast food meals! Can't beat it.

Meat lovers pizza - love the dough, crust and balance of toppings, sauce and crust ratio.

Papas Special pizza - generous toppings and awesome crust. It's slightly thicker than New York style but still fairly thin that's just enough to hold the toppings and not flop on you when you pick up a slice. It's great even the day after a few minutes in the toaster oven. Love it.

Authentic NY style pizza, convenient curbside pickup, and friendly service. I can't believe I didn't discover this place sooner.

By far the best pizza in Brownsburg and the best NY style pizza on the west side. They have delicious breadsticks as well. Pizza is always hot and ready when they say it will be ready.

We have ordered carryout from here several times. The pizza is good and filling. They also have pasta dishes which I have never been dissatisfied with. Good breadsticks and friendly workers.

The best 'Carry-Out' pizza in Brownsburg! Always fast and friendly service! Try the Papa's Special!

Never disappointed with Papas. Despite the humble environment, this place has great Italian food. Papa sampler always hits the spot and kids love chicken alfredo. Salads are hearty and tasty. I believe dressings are house made. Great place to order out from and Brownsburg is lucky to have it along a variety of less appealing restaurants.

Great pizza and pasta! We ordered chicken parm also and that meal was delicious. Definitely will order from here again!