Jimmy Joy's Log Cabin Inn

Spousal Unit needed to travel to Hancock to pick up some fabric for a traveling quilt show and asked me to come along for the ride (i.e., drive). It was dinner time as we were heading back, so we looked on Yelp and Jimmy Joy's Log Cabin Inn. We decided to try it - and are darned glad we did.

Ambiance: it's a log cabin, cozy, with comfortable chairs and table. Not too loud, not to dim, JUUUUST right for my oldish body. Lots of things on the menu, but what was intriguing was the emphasis on crabs. Not what I'd expect being a few hours from the Chesapeake Bay. Looking around at other diners, many - most - were eating crab dishes, so when in Rome...

Food: I asked the waitperson for recommendations; she said crab cakes and crab stuffed potato skins were her personal favs, and added that the crab cakes were at least as good as where she grew up. I asked "Where" was that - and after a few more questions, found out we came from the same neighborhood outside Baltimore. So I knew that she knew her crab cakes - and she wasn't wrong. Broiled cakes made with lots of jumbo meat, very little filler, lightly spiced just to emphasize the sweet meat of the crabs themselves. Excellent choice! SU had the potato skins stuffed with a crab imperial mixture, which she pronounced as "yummy". Portion sizes were good (I scarfed mine down but SU took a few home).

Value: very reasonable cost for an excellent meal. Would I drive 2 hours just to eat there? Probably not - but anytime I head out 70 past Hagerstown I will plan my travel around stopping.

Stopped by for a bite on our way through town, headed to New England. Our party odds 4 was seated immediately and we were offered the AyCE Crab, which we decided against but would have eaten if we were in the middle of a 16 hour drive.
I got the crab cakes with asparagus and mashed potatoes. YUMMY, the crab cakes were filled with chunks and chunks of crab, they do not skimp. Husbands got the fried shrimp which he liked as well. Son got a kids cheeseburger which was hand pressed and cooked perfectly. Daughter got the kids chicken strips and she gobbled them up as well. Our server recommended the Brownie and ice cream for dessert which was delicious as well.
Overall, giving this a 4 for the quality of the food in surprising location. They have a full bar and plenty of seating. Our server was attentive, friendly and had a big smile.
If we pass through I would stop here again.
If you are looking for a good bite at a reasonable price, this is your place. I would recommend this place to anyone in the area.

My favorite place for steamed crabs! Great service by friendly, attentive staff, large portions, delicious soups, Steam crabs year round, all-you-can-eat two nights a week and various size crabs available for purchased by the dozen. I'm a huge fan of raw oysters and they are always tasty here. The bartenders make fantastic margaritas as well as other cocktails. This place is busy on AYCE nights so reservations are needed. I prefer to drive up during the daytime when it's a little quieter, enjoy crabs with friends in a friendly environment. Honestly wish I could get more than five stars because I love this place and visit frequently. It's a must whenever you're in the Hancock, just 30 minutes from Hagerstown and well worth the drive

We've been here a number of times after riding on the WMRT and the food and service have always been excellent! Today was no exception! I reserved a table mid week for 14 of us, and despite showing up 30 minutes early we were seated and received immediate service. Started out with some delicious beers on tap, and then we ordered a whole variety of food, including crabs. Everyone was very happy with their meal! Considering that was 13 of us and we are all quite hungry after our ride, the service provided by Laykn could not have been any better! She was super friendly and incredibly efficient, she checked on us often and kept us happy! Another wonderful experience @ Jimmy Joy's Log Cabin, I'm already looking forward to our next visit!

Good food, good service - it's a simple interior because the effort goes into the food! We will be heading back.

Average meal, ordered shrimp appetizer and chicken salad. A little to much lettuce, not very many toppings. For dessert I ordered key lime pie and husband had strawberry cheesecake. No flavor on key lime pie. Just tasted like vanilla custard. Waitress had NO personality.

The food was great! Best damn crab cakes I've ever had. Don't be afraid to try the slaw if you like it sweet. The potatoe skins with crab are delicious. The staff was on the spot with refills and checking in on you. I highly recommend this place.

We were watching The Wire and saw the detectives eat crabs and had huge cravings for some good crabs. It's March and it's not crab season but we were determined for some crabs! Glad we tried this place.
We had 1 doz crabs with hush puppies and fried haddock. Completely hit the right spot. Love how fresh and juicy their seafood is. Will definitely return!

Great food. Great service. Great environment. Easy on off Rt 70. This is worth the short detour

Biggest crabs I've ever gotten. Our server was fantastic. Drinks were good. Overall a great place for crabs!