Brother's Pizza

These guys make the best pie in Long Branch, BUT they have gotten way too expensive over the last year or two.

I loved the pizza the first time I tried it, but every Uber order since, I have ordered topping on half the pizza, and have received toppings on the whole pizza, which means one of us doesn't get to eat. Very frustrating and a waste of money. If the kitchen could follow what their orders actually are, I would love to be a loyal customer.

Always a great experience! They've been neighborhood spot for years. From enjoying pizza from all over NY & NJ - Brothers can keep up with the rest.
Friendly, great prices, and always great fresh quality!
Thanks for another great slice!

Ordered from them tonight. I've always gotten pizza here which is great but ordered an eggplant parm sub. Outstanding. Best eggplant parm I've ever had. Highly recommend this place.

Second time I ordered from Brothers Pizza 868 Broadway, West Long Branch, New Jersey , 07764. Sampled plain pizza, calzone, chicken parmigiana Stromboli and pasta fagioli. So so good I imagined my grandmother came back to life and was cooking in their kitchen. Highly recommended, they deliver themselves. Gotta try them. Louie the owner is very pleasant. 732 571 7800 From Vincent V.

Always good. Margherita 5 out of 5 Sicilian 5 out of 5. Garlic knots 5 out of 5. Owners are great.

I am a NJ native now living in TN and I have been eating pizza since I was five from all the best pizzerias in NY, NJ. This is the best Margherita Pizza in New Jersey! Louie is the best. Excellent service and food is outrageous and very reasonably priced. Best value in the state. He packed one up special for me to take back to TN... Louie and his staff make for a very pleasant experience, definitely stop by!

I've been enjoying consistently great pizza from this location. I've been ordering for about three years and the only bad experience was a pizza delivered that looked as though it were used as a frisbee! I ordered one with extra cheese and it was just all over the place, but this has also happened with other restaurants that delivered extra cheese pies, so if I want a pie with extra cheese, I will just simply drive and pick it up myself.

Any other pie has always been very good, and most of the times, with toppings, you don't even need the extra cheese. Brother's is probably my favorite now and will mostly continue to use them over the other places I've ordered from. Dinners and subs are just ok, and I wasn't too pleased with their wings. Pizza is what I will stick to and I'm perfectly satisfied with that!

I should have been more influenced by the negative reviews of this restaurant's poor service record and their messing up of orders! Although I had ordered here several times before and had had poor service before, I thought I'd give them another chance because I remembered that the food was quite good. But this place has gotten even worse!

I ordered chicken noodle soup (and got pasta fagiole), my husband's spaghetti and meatballs arrived without the advertised salad. (I was told salad was offered on the OLD menu --- which is what I had --- and did not come with the dish anymore but they were awaiting the new menus any day!)

Based on the menu that I was given on my last visit, I was, this time, overcharged $1.50 for the spaghetti, $1 for the soup and $1.50 on a half sub. I was also charged $2 for delivery whereas my menu said delivery was free for orders over $10. (My order came to $27.50!) In checking my credit card charge, I see they actually charged me $30.50!! So not only are they sloppy businessmen, they are dishonest thieves also!

In addition, the order was promised in 45 minutes but, after calling to inquire about it, it didn't appear until almost twice that time.

I gave Brothers one star because the food was, as before, quite good but I know I won't be patronizing them again. That's their loss. Was losing a customer and getting a scathing review worth $3 to you, Brothers?

Pizza is good but something weird is going on here. I ordered a large pie with pepperoni and a 2 L brisk. Totaling to around 23 dollar pre tax. With tax lets say 25
I got charged 33 dollars. Unless im unaware of other fees here i dont know why there prices are so high. Probably tipping themselves??? I dont know

Ps:
large pie $15
Pepperoni: $3.50
Brisk: $4