Menu
Location & Hours
You Might Also Consider
in Pizza, Italian
in Bars, Italian
Amenities and More
About the Business
2 large pizza free 10 chicken buffalo 2 medium pizza free 2L soda &6 garlic knots
Ask the Community
Yelp users haven’t asked any questions yet about Nico's Pizzeria.
Recommended Reviews
Overall rating
6 reviews
5 stars
4 stars
3 stars
2 stars
1 star
- Gata N.Newark, NJ189112Oct 26, 2018
While I have ordered from here in the past and the food was decent and the people were, also, on *this* occasion they cancelled an order--to a place they previously delivered to--WITHOUT WARNING, *very* freaking close to the estimated delivery time. You don't have customers wait nearly an hour and *then* cancel, stating you don't deliver to the area, when you've delivered here at least six times before.
Wow. Way to get brand new. I can't with you.
EDIT: NEW. OWNER. Okay, then: "Way to *literally* get brand new." NOT.Helpful 3Thanks 0Love this 2Oh no 0 - Cheri D.Bloomfield, NJ4722Feb 8, 2019
A sandwich on a pizza, which we were DEFINITELY in the mood for trying! And let me tell you, Nico's Special did NOT disappoint. Then there's the classic Buffalo chicken pizza and OMG did that hit the spot! No complaints here! Also delivery was timely. I didn't eat my phone while waiting, nor was I tempted to. Good job.
Helpful 1Thanks 0Love this 0Oh no 0 - Bianca B.Bronx, NY1404Aug 20, 2017
HORRIBLE!!! I will never order from then again. I ordered my pizza at 9:30pm and didn't get my pizza until 12:30am. I called maybe 3 times and got the run around. From 11:14 the driver was supposedly out now I was only five minutes from the restaurant. The driver called at around 11:20 and realized he was at the wrong address shows up an hour later with kids in his car, cold pizza and not even the correct order! I call to speak to a manager and obviously only young kids work at night because they're laughing and giving the run around again. Disgusting!
Helpful 4Thanks 0Love this 0Oh no 0 - Marissa J.Little Ferry, NJ2612Apr 2, 2018
I wish I could give negative stars tbh.
I walked in after walking around a bit and the front guy, who was the only employee working it seemed, greeted me rudely and very short. I ordered mozzarella sticks and grabbed a can of soda and a liter of iced tea. It was taking a bit for the food to come out so I expected them to be warm and gooey with cheese. But they came out with barely any cheese in them and the marinara sauce was cold. It's freezing out if you're not in the sun and this guy had the door wide open so I was freezing while I was sitting there. As I'm eating, I finished my soda and needed a cup for my iced tea and the guy gave me a rude attitude about asking for one.
For the quality of the food and the service of the employees, I was surprised the price was what it was.
I'd never go back honestly.Helpful 1Thanks 0Love this 1Oh no 0 - Rell S.Jersey City, NJ01Jan 6, 2018
I wish I can take my 1 star back because it took two and a half hours for one pie only nine blocks away. Then after the long wait they bring me the wrong pizza. Never again for me.
Helpful 1Thanks 0Love this 0Oh no 0
Other Pizza Nearby
in Italian, Salad, Pizza
in Italian, Pizza