Rowdy Hall

We stayed in the Hamptons one weekend and we stopped here for dinner. I was blown away by their espresso martini, it was one if the best I have ever had! For dinner we shared a bunch of apps including the escargot, giant pretzel, and artichoke which were all amazing. My favorite however was the french onion soup, the veal broth was out of this world. It is a must order!

Pros : Service here is on point. The atmosphere is clean and nice.

Cons : The food is nothing special - for starters they changed their burger style, before they relocated from EH they had a legit sesame seed bun, now the bun is a basic generic one you find at a cheap rushed backyard BBQ. I ordered my burger medium, it was totally well done, I couldn't even finish it. Burnt vibes. The fries were overly salty and borderline not edible. I got a chili & cornbread special,l - the chili was fine, but it there was 3x more cornbread than chili, so it was a bad proportion.

End of the day forty-five bucks before tip for a burger with fries and a chili with cornbread appetizer is pretty excessive for how unimpressive it all was.

One and done for me personally.

Lunch 2/3/24. Ordered three onion soups, two burgers and wings. Asked that all be delivered at same time. Soups arrive-very good, though $18. Wings came 15 minutes later. Burgers come another 15 minutes later-lukewarm, not hot. Were they sitting waiting to be delivered to the table? Seems that way. Fries were overcooked. Waitress was very pleasant but the timing and delivery of the food was poor.
Very surprised and disappointed. Renovations were well done.
Rowdy Hall needs to up its game on the actual food preparation and delivery.

Great place in East Hampton tucked away from the Main Street for casual pub fare. The portions are generous without being too much food. French onion soup was deliciously cheesy and the s'mores sundae is not to be missed. It might be one of the best things I've eaten anywhere in town! The homemade seasonal ice cream (peanut butter) was also delicious. On a weekday night after Labor Day it wasn't too crowded and we easily got a table for four. Only downside is that the chairs stick to the floor and it's difficult to move your chair in and out. But that wouldn't stop me at all from going back to or recommending this great place!

Service was excellent! Food came out quickly and was nice and hot with good presentation! The mussels were delicious!

Solid comfort food, good drinks and lovely atmosphere! I won't take a position on the black exterior controversy!

The food was excellent! Loved the escargot and the fluke. My bf got the burger he enjoyed it a lot and his grandma got the French onion soup which she loved! I love how it's sets back on the Main Street with indoor and outdoor dining. Would def go back!

We went to the new Rowdy Hall recently relocated from E Hampton to Amagansett tonight for an early Sunday dinner. The place was pleasantly packed and vibrant. Seventies Classics and Eighties New Wave music played in the background. We were told by the friendly hostesses that we'd perhaps have a 45 minute wait and grabbed drinks at the bar. To our happy surprise just 15 minutes later we were seated. Service was spot on (thanks to our friendly and efficient server, Suri). The elevated pub fare was perfectly cooked, brought swiftly to the table. After a shared shrimp cocktail that would rival that of any seafood restaurant or high end steakhouse, we enjoyed a cheese burger and fish and chips both cooked perfectly and brought to the table piping hot. In essence, it was a perfect, casual Sunday night dinner. We will be back regularly for sure.

I came to amagansett to try the new rowdy hall location. it was always a casual favorite. I think we should all give them time to settle in to their new space. this evening, Rowdy Hall has the distinction of providing the worst service I have ever experienced in all my years of eating out. I sat there for a half hour waiting for my dinner while my companion was served. the waitress disappeared and was unable to produce my meal from the kitchen. it was only after we asked for the manager to come to our table that I eventually got my dinner.
Best of luck Rowdy Hall but for now, what a mess.
Linda Li

Great, casual atmosphere with delicious food and wonderful, professional and friendly service.