Fanatics Pub and Pizza

This was my first time at Fanatic's and it went like this...First off there's plenty of off street parking and easy entrance with a ramp inside for the impaired folks...Now on to the food...I ordered a chicken finger and fries meal and a IPA beer on tap...The beer arrived cold as ice and then the food...Well the chicken fingers were okay I guess, although nothing more than frozen bagged stuff...The sauce was also just okay, like many other pubs...The fries were very dark and oily...The room was cozy with a sort of old school vibe of years gone by...The walls adorned with various acts who have graced the stage over the years...The bill for chicken fingers and two IPA's + tax + tip was around $35.00 give or take...All in all not a bad place for a meal, but nothing I'm rushing back for anytime soon...Give em a try for yourself whenever you're in Lima NY.

I was invited to attend a concert at Fanatics in Lima, NY, to see the Jazz group, The Howard Levy 4. From the moment we walked in, we were greeted very warmly by Norm and a few other regular customers. We arrived early to have a meal. We had chicken wings, two "garbage plates, and the beef and cheddar sandwich. We were all very pleased with our meals, which arrived timely and hot. The bar provides top shelf drinks as well. The live music is played in the back where there is ample seating. To see the bands, you buy tickets and have assigned seating. You can also order food and drinks in here as well. My husband the fried zucchini with ranch, which he enjoyed. I opted for the decadent and very sweet, snicker peanut butter pie with vanilla ice cream, whipped cream and drizzled with chocolate. Delish! Fanatics reminds me of a "cheers" bar where everyone seems to know your name. Fanatics is a gem in this village of Lima!

The food was good- just bar food but good. Our waiter was helpful and quick. They have live music frequently ( this Sunday there was a band). Not huge inside so I imagine it gets a little crazy when bigger bands are there. I wouldn't go out of my way to go there but if I am in Lima, I would definitely stop in for a brew.

Wouldn't kick out disruptive patrons. Recently went here to see my favorite band, The Cold Stares. I love them! But there were three tables surrounding us that were all one party and talked and even shouted over the music to each other. They wouldn't stop and when I complained to mgmt they claimed they couldn't kick them out because there were too many of them. One guy was even pinching and slapping other people on the butt. It was disturbing to say the least. Hot take: You can kick out that many people but you chose not to. You chose to have your establishment favor rowdy disruptive patrons over people who paid to be there to see the band. Couldn't hear the band or concentrate on the songs, mostly heard them.

Ordered here for the first time and all the food was excellent. I got take out, but being inside I noticed a great atmosphere and good crowd.

Fanatics brings amazing musicians in to a small town atmosphere. I've always had a great time there!

This place is an underrated gem!! Their wings (with their signature Fanatic's sauce--a blend of Buffalo and country sweet) are my family's favorite!! They are plump, juicy, with the perfect blend of sweet & savory! The staff are always incredibly friendly and their weekly trivia nite every Wednesday is highly recommended for the entertainment value alone!

This place is the best
The music is off the wall would never expect this kind of music and food from a sports bar
To me this is not a sports bar it's a classy restaurant
The locals are awesome
Pub wings
Beef on wick
Specials all the time
You have to try this place
Mark & Jennifer Foodie

Absolutely the best live Blues artists in Western NY.
Nice place for a drink and dinner too.

Walking in, we were greeted with a warm friendly smile from Tara our bartender. She was efficient, knowledgeable and attentive. After spending only a few hours here, it was evident that this is the kind of establishment that makes everyone feel welcome. Regulars were greeted by name and everyone entering was happy to spend a few hours enjoying some refreshing pints, delicious food and the company of people who very much felt like that were at a home away from home. Big screen tvs were available to watch games along with quick draw for those looking to gamble a bit!

Overall, I would recommend this wonderful little gem to anyone looking for a good time with great people!