Menu
Review Highlights
Location & Hours
Sea Isle City, NJ 08243
You Might Also Consider
Savory Meets Sweet
NEW Peanut Butter Puppy Chow Blizzard® Treatin Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt
Time For A Dunkin' Run
$1, $2, & $3 Food Deals W/ A Medium Coffee.in Coffee & Tea, Donuts, Breakfast & Brunch
Amenities and More
Ask the Community
Q:
Status needs to be changed was hoping to go today as it still says open. Can someone update status?
A:
Recommended Reviews
Your trust is our top concern, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more.
Overall rating
5 stars
4 stars
3 stars
2 stars
1 star
438138735727/23/2021And YUM YUMS IT SURE IS!
My big cup of three sumptuous flavors (my all time favorite, Cookies n Cream, Death by Chocolate, Cake and Ice-cream) were all outstanding!
Three huge scoops, all on top of each other, as opposed to next to each other, which surprised me, (but I loved it as such!)!
Business was popping with very happy patrons, for very good reason!
Young servers bustin' their butts and Yum Yums is ran like a well oiled machine! CASH ONLY. Remember to tip!
Please try here!!!i
Tyler N.Eagleville, PA3749/17/2022WORST MILKSHAKE I'VE EVER TASTED!!! Their milkshake tastes exactly like sour milk mixed with sugar and chlorine. Fuckin horrible. Also got a cone with one scoop of cookie dough. Ice cream was okay but kinda bland. Cone was stale as hell. Their sign out front literally looks like a 5 year old painted it with crayons. $16 bucks for one scoop of bland ice cream and an atrocious milkshake. Total fuckin rip. Avoid!!
1772244216/9/2020Updated reviewThere is nothing better than ending a great beach day with ice cream! Things look a little different this year but the quality is just as good.
I ordered at the front window and my ice cream was ready within five minutes! Bonus-you can smell the waffle cones being made.
There are tons of flavors to choose from so there really is something for everyone here. Aside from your normal cups and cones, there are also sundaes, waffle sandwiches, shakes and more! My waffle cone ended up being about $6 but for the amount of ice cream and quality, I think the price is on par. Definitely recommend!
Business owner information
Ryan M.
6/9/2020
Thank you for your review Stephanie. Trying out some new things this summer with COVID-19 and installing the take away window during the slower times was one of the bigger decisions we made. Glad to hear it worked well for you.
6/26/2019Previous reviewEvery time I travel, I like to find a local place for ice cream. Yum yum a definite did not disappoint. Once you walk in, you smell the waffles and waffle cones being freshly prepared (smart marketing!).
There are at least 30 flavors to choose from and it's definitely hard to make a decision. I had the cookies and cream and peanut butter cup flavors in a waffle cone. The ice cream is delicious and creamy and the perfect way to end a beach day.
There are also plenty of fun sundaes and topics available also.
2722734797/7/2020First off let me start by saying I'm an icecream junkie- especially when it comes to beach towns with all the interesting flavors. Yum Yums menu did not disappoint with so many yummy options I was honestly overwhelmed. Thank goodness we were allowed inside (with a mask of course) as seeing the flavors allowed me to make my decision. I decided on toasted coconut. The consistency was perfect- Not rock hard (the worst in my opinion) and the size ideal. Had gone to maritas (other local icecream shop) the night before and the size was minuscule. Yum Yums line was out the door which always speaks volumes to me. Not to mention there was a cute little candy at the bottom of the cone! Note: they take credit cards unlike maritas! Would definitely return.
Covid situation: you can only enter the store if you have a mask on. Plastic barriers along the entire counter. Hand sanitizer as you enter and one way flow of traffic markings on the floor. Young lady outside taking orders if you do not have a mask with you.
22069967/19/2020I've heard good things about this place so it was on my list when we went to sea isle for the day. Their menu was huge, with so many different ice cream flavors. Luckily I came with friends so I could have a taste of more than one flavor. I ordered a scoop of death by chocolate. Being a big fan of chocolate - I really enjoyed my ice cream! I would love to come back and try their other flavors.
Alexandria S.Coolidge Corner South Side, Brookline, MA020308/4/2022Always the best ice cream. The most flavors. The line is always out the door basically around the block but they move fast and are well worth the wait. Best Ice cream of sea isle!
Hayley L.Lake Mohawk, Sparta, NJ3551218/4/2021Cute spot near the water. A little overpriced but the ice cream was really good. I got the dulce de luce and it was really good, but my sister got the snickers and it was amazing. Huge chunks of caramel inside!!
Joshua J.Emmaus, PA42043587/3/2019The best place for ice cream in sea isle city.
Come for the ice cream. Leave with the most amazing ice cream at 11pm with a waffle sandwich possible.
Amazing.
Gioia D.Philadelphia, PA010138/11/2021Can't believe people wait that length of time to get ice cream! No tasting due to COVID so hope you're scoop is YumYums
951017395/10/2016This is definitely my favorite place for ice cream in Sea Isle! It is definitely worth the wait in line... I know it goes out the door most nights in the summer but just wait and you will see how creamy and delicious their ice cream is.
My favorite is the Black Raspberry Blast. I get it every time. They have the best one here and can't seem to find it like this anywhere else. What makes it so special is definitely the chocolate pieces that are filled with raspberry in it! It just makes the ice cream that much better. I also recommend their hot fudge...its thick, gooey, and has great flavor. I was so excited to see them open for Mother's Day weekend. I can't wait to go back this summer :)
*Tip: CASH ONLY! (like most places at the shore)
