Menu
Review Highlights
“I got the Filet Tipped Mac n Cheese and my fiancé got the 21 burger (wagu burger).” in 1 reviews
$18 The 21 Burger“Not to mention he brought us our drink refills without asking, and I honestly can't remember the last time I did not have to ask for a refill when I went out.” in 2 reviews
“My wife and I are leaving Indiana and moving to another state.” in 2 reviews
Location & Hours
You Might Also Consider
in Bars, Burgers, Fast Food
in Chicken Shop, Fast Food, Chicken Wings
Amenities and More
About the Business
Business owner information
Joshua B.
Prodigy Burger & Bar opened its doors to Clay Terrace and the greater Carmel area in Fall of 2017. Brought to you by the owners of Prime 47 Carmel, the team at Prodigy invites you to experience a unique destination in dining. Just shy of a successful year later, we're expanding to Kokomo, Indiana! We made our mark creating craft burgers with unique combinations to delight anyone who tries them. As one of the only local places to offer Wagyu Burgers, hand-crafted sandwiches, and a wide array of small plate style appetizers, you will not leave our restaurant hungry or disappointed. Catch a game while enjoying fantastic food at a lively bar featuring 20 Taps, 60+ Bourbons, Boozy Milkshakes and much more! Come check out Carmel's hottest gathering place in Clay Terrace and Kokomo's newest specialty burger location. Join us today to experience Prodigy Burger & Bar for yourself!
Ask the Community
Yelp users haven’t asked any questions yet about Prodigy Burger Bar Kokomo.
Recommended Reviews
Overall rating
39 reviews
5 stars
4 stars
3 stars
2 stars
1 star
- B B.Grandview Heights, Columbus, OH71209Aug 9, 2019
Great locally owned spot. Very cool and trendy. Upbeat atmosphere and amazing beer selection.
We had the goat, greatest of all time burger! Eat your heart out McDonald's fans, because this is what the Big Mac should taste like!
Amazing daily specials also!! We will be back to try the ribs!Helpful 0Thanks 0Love this 0Oh no 0 - Michael K.Lafayette, IN012Mar 30, 2024
Food was mediocre. I've had way better burgers elsewhere. Just wasn't impressed by it. Onion rings were overcooked and very crispy.
Helpful 0Thanks 0Love this 0Oh no 0 - Rogelio G.Kokomo, IN01Mar 30, 2024
Disappointing service and very passive aggressive staffing members. Save your money and time.
Helpful 0Thanks 0Love this 0Oh no 0 - Alec D.Upland, IN06Mar 24, 2024
Overall a decent experience. The staff was nice and attentive so 5/5 for service. The food was where our experience was a bit lacking. I built my own burger which is great for options. But when it costs $2 to add bacon, and then the burger has 2 pieces on it, about 2.5 inches long, that isn't worth it. We also got truffle fries and they had a very light dusting of the truffle seasoning, so the extra up charge wasn't worth it. Overall I would come back here again as the food is good. But be careful with which items/upgrades you add to your meal.
Helpful 0Thanks 0Love this 0Oh no 0 - Syd M.Citrus Heights, CA01Oct 28, 2023
I just wanted to provide a warning for my fellow gluten free people.
I got glutened here. The waitress did come running over half way through to tell me that she didn't put the gluten free order in. So I at least had time to prepare for the longest hour drive home of my life.
As I sit here in extreme pain I just wanted to warn my fellow allergy people to be careful.Helpful 0Thanks 0Love this 0Oh no 0 - Patricia A.San Francisco, CA02Jun 12, 2023
The food was served cold.
The manager seemed extremely disinterested in customer satisfaction nor seemed to have any interest in upholding your company's signature dish reputation. To give a bill and flat out lie about food service was unacceptable inappropriate and flat out disrespectful and left a horrible taste in prodigy's restaurant. He insulted not only my husband but my mother in law my brother and sister who were all visiting from out of state. Hoping to share with them a wonderful evening nice food atmosphere and good company. Instead we received cold and disrespectful degrading service from the manger in charge.Helpful 1Thanks 1Love this 0Oh no 0 - Cal W.IN, IN02612Aug 8, 2023
Convenient location. Excellent food and fast service. Sports bar feel with outstanding burgers. Love the build your own option. Took several customers there for lunch. Will be back
Helpful 0Thanks 0Love this 0Oh no 0 - Hayden S.Denver, IN03May 7, 2023
This place used to be good, but now it's terrible. The food is horrible. They served rotten fruit to my daughter! Cold fries, burger soup, the burger was swimming in oil. I've tried to give it a chance over the last 6 months but we're done now.
Helpful 1Thanks 1Love this 1Oh no 0 - Aaron B.IN, IN01May 26, 2023
HORRIBLE FOOD!!! I've NEVER left a review for anything, but the food here was so BAD I don't want anyone to order and eat here! I only ordered a Mac n Cheese and BLT and ALL of it was HORRIBLE!!! Run run run to another restaurant!!!
Helpful 0Thanks 1Love this 0Oh no 0 - Derrick M.IN, IN22Feb 14, 2023
one time I had one of the greatest burgers & fries & shakes dining experience at Prodigy Burger kokomo. Another time, it was good. The other 4 times I tried to eat here are some of my worst experiences in poor restaurant service/management. ponderous wait times while employees banter. some of the worst bartenders I've ever witnessed. basics like silverware and napkins are a luxury. amazing dichotomy to have my best and worst burgers come from the same spot. ... sometimes, I think about managing this place just out of some sort of altruism. they have a great product. if the owner/CEO / manager is reading this: 100k /year, and I'll turn this into one of the hottest spots in kokomo. band management just trickles down into terrible dining experiences.
Helpful 1Thanks 1Love this 0Oh no 0
You Might Also Consider
in Salad, Sandwiches, Delis
in Steakhouses