Pizzaro Flamed Baked Pizza

Our go-to spot for pizza. The oven-fired pizza dough is terrific. The tomato sauce with our choice of mushrooms & onions brings us back repeatedly. The jumbo pizza is a steal on the night that it is discounted (Tuesdays).

Just drove by today and saw the place was empty and there was a sign on the door that said that they are permanently closed. I loved the food here. It was always delicious and made with fresh ingredients! I am sad to see it close!

Craving pizza this Sunday afternoon so instead of committing to an entire pizza and feeing guilty about it I found a shop that did pizza slices.

Pretty good red sauce and the crust was great. Didn't care for the white Pizza that much. No real distinct flavors except the spinach.

We were looking for a lunch that was not fast-food but also not a long sit-down meal. This seems like a mom-n-pop kind of place; the staff are friendly and clearly were working hard, the place is older but clean. It wasn't packed and the food came out within minutes (compared to the Panera next door, which was very busy and very backed up). We ordered a Philly steak and cheese and a slice of cheese pizza--a simple order--it was tasty, ingredients fresh. The menu is traditional for this kind of place but we thought it was a solid choice!

Been coming here for years. The pizza is consistent. There is something about the crust that is addicting. Nothing fancy-great for take out.

The waiters were really nice. Social distancing is being followed and wearing masks. I had high hopes for the garlic knots because of the previous reviews but unfortunately the night o went the garlic knots didn't seem fresh and didn't have much flavor. The garlic bread just tasted like bread no actual garlic flavor. We ordered the deluxe pizza, plenty of toppings for sure. Loaded with toppings which is great however there was hardly any cheese or sauce on the pizza so there wasn't much balance. I'm not sure if they put the toppings first and then sprinkle cheese on top, but there was hardly any cheese. The crust was pretty yummy, the dough itself had a nice fluffy flavor. I'd probably give it another chance but next time just one topping, the other pizzas looked like they had enough cheese.

Solid --- my daughter loved the chicken Caesar salad A+
Garlic bread --C average at best
pizza --B+ very interesting-- sweet crust -- definitely NOT generic Sysco sauce

id definitely recommend this to anyone!!!

I decided to try something different for dinner other than the usual chain pizza places.

I checked out the special features they had on the website. Since it was Thursday the special of the day was 1 large pizza, 12 wings, and 10 garlic knots for $20.99. Seemed like a good deal so we decided to go for it.

I called to place my order over the phone for delivery. The guy that took my order seemed like he was barely awake. Asked for my phone number then there was a long pause and then he came back on the line and asked for the address that I had to spell out word for word letter by letter about 5 times...jeez it was painful talking to this guy over the phone. Once we got through the painful process of getting the address, he incompetently fumbled through the computer on his end to take my order. Whomever decided to put this guy on phone orders clearly has never heard this person over the phone. The ordering process was like pulling teeth having to ask every little detail. It got to the point where I didn't feel comfortable with giving this guy my credit card information. I opted to pay cash requiring me to drive to the nearest ATM and withdraw cash to pay the delivery guy.

On to the food...it was good. The wings were crispy and overly salty, but there were plentiful and good size. I probably wouldn't order it again.

When it comes to pizza, the wife and I are pretty boring and usually at least get a cheese pizza. It was fresh, cheese tasted fresh but the crust wasn't flavorful or pleasant to eat. The base was good and as can be expected from a flame cooked pizza. The sauce had good taste and the large pizza is certainly filling. Plenty of leftovers. I'd get the pizza again and maybe even try some more toppings.

The garlic knots were terrible. No taste. Too doughy. Too dry. I definitely wouldn't get them.

Overall, I'd give this place another go but maybe just order the pizza and DEFINITELY not place it over the phone.

DIABEETUS... that's the first word that comes to my mind. Followed by sugar cookie (which I know is two words) followed by Twinkie (which is not a real word).

So I don't really mind that the place is a little rundown. I had some of my best pizza in a hole in the wall in Little Italy in Boston. I care about the quality of the food. But here's the thing the pizza was cooked perfectly. The ingredients were decent. The crust was cooked well - crispy but soft on the inside. The salad was crisp. ...

But that dough it's awful. Is so sweet.
It's like eating an unfrosted donut.
It's like sweet dinner rolls.
It's like they used grape juice to moisten the dough.
It's like a sweet mexican roll.
It's like a gluten free cupcake.
It's like Buddy the Elf added syrup while making pizza.

It's just really disconcerting to get a bite of sweet when you want savory. So maybe this will work for your little ankle biter who wants sugar on everything. It's not for me. Sorry Pizzaro. I wanted to like you. Love the name and the dingy place. But in the end it's all about the pizza.

I just tried this place for the first time and unfortunately I did not like anything. I wanted to try it based on recent reviews and being local. I may have just gotten them on an off day. Dough is bit thick and gummy. Wings were cooked to almost nothing. Well overdone. And the dipping sauce? I'm not sure what it was; tasted almost like mayonnaise with a few herbs.... I was really hoping to like this place. I may try them again just to see if it was just a bad day for them. I will update my review to let you know how that goes...

I used to be a frequent customer. How frequent you ask... I was there so often that I'd walk up to the register, say hi to the owner, I'd say that I wanted the usual, and he'd know exactly what I wanted and how I wanted it. I hadn't gone as frequently due to my work schedule.
I decided to head back yesterday and had something that I hadn't had in a while. I had a Gyro. In fact, it was one of the best gyros that I've had in a while. It was meaty and tender. The pita was done to perfection. The tzatziki sauce was amazing and fresh. I darn near bit my finger eating it.

I'll be back sooner than later and it looks like I'll have a new usual.