Margaritaville

Great place to stay! Only big downfall was breakfast is NOT included. Resort is amazing and the staff is EXTREMELY friendly.

The most expensive food we had on the island, by a long shot and unfortunately the worst.
We expected the food to be better after a 45 minute wait. Not only for the wait but typically when you're hungrier the food tastes better.

We got the Caribbean egg rolls for a starter- 5/10
The fish tacos- 4/10 ( SO DRY!!!!)
And the mango tango salmon- 9/10.

Absolutely the worst place when you visit the resort we sat there for 25 minutes until a waitress finally came then it took another 40 minutes for our food then if you trying to get a refill you have to beg the waitress to come but there is a great view overall restaurant sucks and service sucks

Bring a deck of cards.

It took us about an hour and 40 minutes to get our food on a not-busy Wednesday evening. We would not have eaten here had it not been our first night in on the island. The staff doesn't really care how long it takes or if they get your food, right - 18% gratuity is included with every ticket, so why would it matter? I ordered a drink that took 30 minutes itself to come out. The wait staff forgot many things about our order - I don't think she put it in when we ordered. Also, drinks are not like pictured on menu. The margarita I ordered looked at least like a 20 ounce. It was maybe 12 ounces for $12. If this place had been reasonable in waiting on us, we probably would've been here several times during our stay, but we will not waste our time here. Who wants to waste two hours of their vacation just waiting on food to be served. Two stars, because the scenery is nice, the drinks were good, and the food was ok.

This is a fun resort and within a 5 minute walking distance to Coki beach which has the best food on the island in my opinion.

Both pools are beautiful! There is entertainment and something going on on the property everyday.

The restaurant on the property is pretty good. They have a nice selection of food on their menu. One of my favorites is the seafood soup, it is delicious! I also really like the nachos, they will feed 4 or 5 people easily.

The staff is friendly and they have a shuttle that will pick you up at your room and take you anywhere you want to go on the property.

There is also a market on the property that serves good sandwiches and breakfast items.

I have stayed here several times and look forward to visiting again.

We were staying at Point Pleasant Resort, which is a short walk from the Margaritaville in St. Thomas. Even though we were not staying at their resort, we were able to eat at their restaurant, walk the grounds, and enjoy their coffee shop. The pool area was off-limits without a wristband, and the wi-fi was only available if you had a room number.

At the restaurant, for their happy hour, they offer buy one, get one drinks. I recommend their Havana Banana drink, which has rum, creme de banana, Bailey's irish cream, and pina colada mix.

We ate dinner their twice. One time, we had their volcano nachos, which were absolutely delicious. My husband and I shared them and still had left overs. The next night, we tried their taco salad. It was just okay. Everything was mixed together on the plate. On the menu, the picture showed the items layered rather than mixed. You wouldn't think it would make that big a difference, but unfortunately, it did. However, the guacamole was really good.

The view from the outside seating area by the bar is gorgeous, and the grounds crew does a great job keeping the resort beautiful! The beach, however, is not spectacular with just a narrow strip of sand.

The next morning, we stopped at the coffee shop. They offer breakfast sandwiches, coffee, pastries, and other sweets. I had the turtle cheesecake it was great. My husband tried the chocolate cake. He said it was just ok.

THIS IS FOR THE RESTAURANT ONLY!

Overall HORRIBLE experience,except for the view. If you are here for views only, I suggest it . Otherwise, the service was horrible and waitress was extremely rude. I asked to upgrade my shrimp salad with coconut shrimp and she said I couldn't, which I thought was odd. I thought perhaps she thought I wasn't willing to pay an up-charge so I clarified I'd being will to pay an up-charge, and I asked her what the up charge would be. She said it would be the same as the coconut shrimp entree. That was priced just about $6 higher So I was like oh okay so $24 instead of $18? And she said yeah. I looked at my fiancé for confirmation and he said "yeah do it" and I was like okay cool I think that's fair too, I'll do that. Because everything is so expensive here anyways what's another $6 ! I was then served my salad and brought out the entire coconut shrimp entree too (which had the coconut shrimp in a separate side dish, by the way, so not sure what it cant just be swapped out). So I said "oh no I just ordered the coconut shrimp, not the entire meal". The food runner left the shrimp and walked over to my server to tell her the situation. She came over and I said I was confused and OBVIOUSLY didn't want to pay for two meals. She acted like that's what I agreed to and gave me a rude look like I was dumb, and took the shrimp away. She took it off the bill but , as a server myself, handled it extremely poorly.
The grilled shrimp were extremely fishy, lettuce wily, and the salad had canned fruit in it. We went here because we are staying at the resort but I recommend going anywhere else unless you're ordering maybe apps. 5 o clock somewhere is an awesome bar by the pool maybe head there!

Firstly I will say that we have been here before. Before Covid. The food was so good we stayed at Margaritaville and came here to eat every night!

Things are apparently different. The food was substandard, the service was worse. I will never come here again. Apparently, word is out because no one else is here.

We stayed at the resort, ordered from the restaurant a few times for snacks by the pool (nacho volcano was delicious but feeds more than two!) and had a sit-down lunch once. Service was very slow at the sit down lunch, and my taco salad did not come with the avocado or corn/bean salsa - I had to ask for these portions of the salad separately and only then was told they didn't have the corn salsa. The avocado was not fresh.

They only take cash or credit card; room charges are not accepted at this time (not sure why).

We stayed at Point Pleasant Resort next to Margarita Villa but luckily we were able to walk along the beach to dine at Margaritaville. I am completely shocked that this pool side restaurant has such low rating on Yelp. I only found out after eating here 5 times and I am glad I didn't look it up prior because I would've thought about it twice and we would've missed out on some delicious drinks and food.
Some negative reviews mention the food choices being limited and expensive. Although these menu items are pricey I think for it being St.Thomas is pretty average and yes, I agree the menu is limited but this is a pool side bar/restaurant the choices are catered to all different age groups including children. They do have a very good 2 for 1 happy hour every day from 4-6 we definitely took advantage of this as much as we could.
My husband and I had lunch and drinks at this place 4 out of the 8 nights we stayed in St.Thomas and I must say it never disappointed. Service was great and the food was flavorful. We had several menu items including the fire fire shrimp (highly recommend if you like spicy) cheese burger, club sandwich (my husband ordered this every time we came, he said it was the most delicious club sandwich he's ever had) quesadilla (highly recommend). Drinks were always made well with a healthy alcohol pour. We had painkillers, buschwacker, mai tais and my husband enjoyed the summer ale. The service was always friendly and attentive. We will definitely come back to Margaritaville and we would love to stay on this property. The grounds are very nice and well kept, the pool area is clean and the view is gorgeous.