Kermit's Key West Key Lime Shoppe

Best Key Lime Pie in Key West. No question!
The Key Lime Cookies are excellent!

My boyfriend and I tried five different Key Lime Pies. I will not discuss the competition. I will say, there is no strong competition. Kermit's is the best.

The cost of one slice is reasonable. The pie is served cold and with a warm friendly smile.

They do have a place to sit down and enjoy your pie. If not, you can get it to-go.

This is a small shop along Duval that--surprise!--sells key lime products. They have a little outdoor back patio if you want to sit and eat there. Obviously, you can take your food to go, if you wish.

The key lime pie was good. It's not as sweet as some places and you can definitely taste the tart key lime flavor, if that appeals to you. It had a good balance of sweet and tart.

Nice enough shop and good pie.

If you want a tasty key lime pie, this is the place to go.
It may not be very spacious but there is a patio in the back where you can eat your pie. However, you may need to take your pie home to enjoy the pie in comfortable surroundings.
Service with a smile is also available here.
Parking will be a challenge so walking here will be easier.
Buying a whole pie is a colossal saving over the price of eight single slices.

TANGY KEY LIME PIE
Stopped by while walking around. There was nobody in there but the friendly staff. I decided to try the chocolate dipped key lime pie. The pie was very tangy but the chocolate brought some balance. If I go back, I would try a regular slice.

Before coming to Key West, my sis told me I MUST come here bc there is no better key lime pie out there. We stopped here after our day out and this was the perfect ending to the day! This is the smaller of the 2 shops in key west but there's a cute little patio out back to sit and relax with your pie. I'm no connoisseur but it was tasty and tart and there's a variety of key lime pie cookies, candies, honey etc. there's even a gluten free key lime pie and cookie! I have to check out the other location with the koi pond but this was on the way back to the port from the Hemingway House.

This store is just such a delight. Everything we taste tested here was absolutely DELICIOUS. Everything we got from here was fantastic, from the key lime fudge, to the classic key lime pie and the coconut key lime pie. My favorite, however, was the coconut key lime pie slice. Next time I'm getting the whole pie!

The ladies at the service counter were so sweet and answered all our questions, and the store is nice and airy, a sunny disposition all around!

Kermit's was such a fun spot to visit. They have so many key lime related products and what's great is that they offer samples! We got to try their cookies, fudge, peanuts, and taffy. Ended up getting bags of cookies to bring back for ourselves, friends and family. They also offer samples of key lime dog treat which our pup loved very much. Key lime pies are pretty good, a little sour for my taste but good regardless. Kermit's in Duval is definitely worth a visit if you're in the area!

My family voted the Kermit's key lime pie as the favorite on the island. The pie here has the perfect balance of tart and sweet. The consistency is also perfect - not too firm and not too liquidy.
There are several Kermit locations and they all sell the same products. The location here though, had the most samples to try. The key lime jelly beans are so good- slightly tart. The cookies that we tried were flaky and flavorful. The salt water taffy was soft and chewy and had a citrusy flavor. I don't normally like salt water taffy but this didn't taste like a normal taffy.
The first time we came into the store (yes, we came multiple times), it was to purchase the limeade. It was such a refreshing citrusy drink!

Get the chocolate covered key lime pie on a stick. It's spectacular!!!
Regular key lime pie is available, too. So are some key lime cookies, peanuts and fudge.

So many fun key lime themed foods and gifts! Staff is super nice and friendly, especially with their great recommendations. We came in for key lime pie on a stick and it was well worth it! My fiancé got it covered in chocolate and I got it covered in white chocolate. Both were delicious but I definitely enjoyed the white chocolate more as it was lighter and didn't mess with the key lime pie flavor as much. Super dense yet still light and fluffy, like cheesecake! Definitely go try it. They have other delicious key lime flavored snacks too. The cookies were also delicious!