Glenn S. Caldwell Insurance Services
Photos & videos
Services Offered
Verified by Business
Car and truck insurance
Homeowner or property
Life insurance
Vehicle
Review Highlights
“Caldwell insurance handles both my life insurance and business insurance needs.” in 2 reviews
“The quote we received was beyond fair and were so pleased with the friendliness of Shannon - both on the phone and through her emails.” in 2 reviews
About the Business
We are a truly local, independent insurance agency serving Tuolumne and Calaveras county for more than 25 years. The owners, Candice, and Justin Myers are second-generation insurance professionals whose goals are to protect your hard-earned assets. We offer all types of insurance including, business owners, workers compensation, homeowners, auto, health, life, and liability.
Location & Hours
Ask the Community
Yelp users haven’t asked any questions yet about Glenn S. Caldwell Insurance Services.
Recommended Reviews
Overall rating
11 reviews
5 stars
4 stars
3 stars
2 stars
1 star
- Jane B.San Francisco, CA24Aug 3, 2020
I have had an excellent experience with Matt Frediani. Thanks for your help Matt.
Helpful 0Thanks 0Love this 0Oh no 0 - John P.Coulterville, CA020May 23, 2020
I had a commercial policy for my business buildings with them for several years. This year in February I received a non renewal letter from the carrier, I am sure they also got a copy also. Just in case I sent an email to them. Like all the other emails I send to them no response. In mid-April I get a call that they are working on it. It expires May 1st. Then a few days prior the expiration they send me a quote that is triple. My buildings are suddenly valued at a rate that is $400,000. more than last year. So I called and asked why they are increasing the value suddenly. They said you were undervalued. Having built many buildings in the last 47 years that was a hard sell to me. I gave them the true current costs and I was actually over in the first place. Then they couldn't change until they got in touch with Justin (owners son in law). Higher premium higher profit.
Then the day before it expires I get a new quote at 3:pm they call and ask if I want to go through with this quote. This time they were trying to sell me an extra coverage for cyber attacks, on steel buildings? This is what I call railroading. I don't have to get insurance, it is just an option. So I shopped around and got a better price by $500.
This is usually the way it works when kids take over a business from a parent. They are suddenly bid shots but don't know how the business was built.
My dealings with them on another transaction was less than trustworthy also.Helpful 0Thanks 0Love this 0Oh no 0 - Dennis G.Oakdale, CA1132Jul 19, 2017
During the wild fires raging in Mariposa County inJuly 2017 I called Shannon Fountain to request additional coverage on the structure that was just built on my property ,wanting to keep ahead of a bad situation I was afraid it wouldn't get covered in time ,but Shannon is Truly a professional and understanding person to help push the coverage through in one day, can't say enough good things about this company and their employees I have my home and vehicles with them and have never experienced a problem, I highly referred them if you're in the market for a great insurance company.
Helpful 0Thanks 0Love this 0Oh no 0 - Nick C.Orange County, CA017Nov 8, 2018
Nobody better than the team at Caldwell. Professional, capable, and responsive. As good as it gets!
Helpful 1Thanks 0Love this 0Oh no 0 - Brandi L.Soulsbyville, CA1770Jun 21, 2016
Caldwell insurance handles both my life insurance and business insurance needs. They stay on top of all my policies to be sure that I have the best coverage and deals. They are easy to reach and very accommodating.
Helpful 1Thanks 0Love this 0Oh no 0 - T L.Menlo Park, CA02Jul 25, 2019
we are working with Diego Contreras, he took over our account and has been very nice to work with, he got everything taken care of in a very fast time frame. Very professional and i know that if i need anything he will be able to help. great job
Helpful 0Thanks 0Love this 0Oh no 0 - Marla W.Tuolumne, CA09Nov 26, 2017
I have had the pleasure of doing business with this agency for several years. I have always received excellent service and what few problems I have had with the insurance companies, they were always able to resolve to my satisfaction. This agency is extremely knowledgeable and I would highly recommend them. They are a long-standing, family business who support our community in addition to providing excellent services.
Helpful 0Thanks 0Love this 0Oh no 0 - John F.Jamestown, CA09Apr 27, 2016
I used FARMERS for years for my painting company. Then I met Justin Myers with Caldwell
Insurance. He actually took the time to educate me on my insurance needs. I am saving a good amount of money each year ( about $400) and getting BETTER insurance coverage.
AND I get the customer service I want. I have found Caldwell Insurance to be a great
business!!!Helpful 0Thanks 0Love this 0Oh no 0 - L M.Sonora, CA0485Feb 9, 2017
These great people helped us get the homeowner's policy on our new home purchased in Sonora. The quote we received was beyond fair and were so pleased with the friendliness of Shannon - both on the phone and through her emails. Once we are permanently settled in the area we will definitely use Glenn S. Caldwell Insurance Services again. Thank you for helping us make our dream a reality.
Helpful 0Thanks 0Love this 0Oh no 0 - Kim A.ID, ID263014Aug 30, 2017
We recently moved our business insurance to Caldwell Insurance Services. We have received an immediate response to all our requests for assistance. Matt and Bobbi are great to work with and can help with business and personal insurance needs. Very happy with our new company!
Helpful 0Thanks 0Love this 0Oh no 0