Caddy's Treasure Island

Breakfast and lunch were good. Service is very good. Too bad it was Saturday game day and the old gambling degenerates take over the beach bar. Creepy old guy vibe at beach bar.Don't go on game day is my advice.

This was our first trip to John's Pass and Caddy's was recommended as a good place to eat. They have a couple of docks overlooking the water that made for a great lunch spot. The drink menu was large and we wound up ordering Painkillers and Pina Colada's in souvenir cups. Drinks were excellent and we have cups to remember this place!

We ordered a large Bavarian pretzel to start. Our entrees ranged from my Mahi tacos to salads to burgers. The food was better than your typical bar food, no complaints.

Our server was extremely friendly. I'd recommend stopping here to eat if you're in the area.

We spent four days on Treasure Island and after recovering from some jetlag, flying coast to coast on a redeye flight, we walked from our VRBO to Caddy's for some drinks. Being a Friday afternoon it was crowded but not too crowded to be uncomfortable. People were on the beach, in the water and Caddy's was hopping with music and people enjoying the food and drink.

My significant other and I made our way upstairs to the bar and took a see look out over the Gul of Mexico. It was a beautiful day and the bar, was not really crowded approaching 5pm in the afternoon. I started with a Pineapple Mojito and she with a Bahama Mama. Honestly, our bartender made these drinks really strong, we got our $15 worth but decided to go back for a second round.

In between our drinks we decided to order food. I went with a simple fish and chips, while my girlfriend did the mahi tacos. I was pleased with my fish, really hard to screw it up, but it was a nice piece of haddock. The mahi tacos weren't great. Coming from California, we know good fish tacos and this attempt was lacking flavor, somewhat cold and not really enjoyed. The second round of drinks saw a Rocky Margarita and a Pain Killer come our way.

Before we knew it we were stuffed and stumbling down the road to get home. It was great fun, the drinks were quality and I was pleased with my food. Might not recommend the fish tacos, but their are other good offerings on the menu.

The staff was very friendly and accommodating and were always asking if we needed anything, while giving us space and time to relax, eat and drink. We decided to hit Caddy's after attending our all day seminar on Sunday. We stopped by had a few rounds of drinks. I swear we weren't trying to get to all the drinks they made, but ended up with Cucumber Mojito, the Spiked Strawberry Lemonade, a Bahama Mama (again!) and a Mai Tai. While not as strong we skipped the food and just relaxed, enjoying the warm weather, breeze and the vibes that Caddy's had to offer

The food is good similar to bar food and the drinks are what you would expect.

The service is casual - sometimes you get a friendlier waiter, than other times... The good times are really fun.

The live music is special- I prefer to sit right near the music and have evening cocktails with my people, listening to music and having a few drinks. And please, for the love of everything, good and holy in this world, please make sure to tip the musician and clap after each song - I can't believe I have to write this down!

The ambience is well... Spectacular!

You're right on the water's edge, looking out on the beach. Chairs are available for rental, simply walk out into the beach and ask for a chair with a umbrella and they'll serve you. Bring cash to tip.

The place is expensive, but heck you're in Treasure Island, so make sure you bring your bounty with you and these pirates will make sure to lighten your booty.

Now be careful parking. It's a tricky place you must pay to park in the parking lot. There's no street parking do not make a mistake because it will be an expensive one.

Overall a great spot, so enjoy it!

Food: I ordered the mahi tacos and my opinion they were bland and dry. The sauce on the taco was good.

The service was very slow. our waitress was busy and didn't pay us much attention the entire meal.

The ambience was nice until the sunset and we were in the complete dark... We were sitting outside but there were no lights near us.

I understand how some may like this place, but with so many other better restaurants with beach views, I would not return!

We were visiting the area and the beach. This is a very convenient location if you are at the beach! They have indoor and outdoor seating. They also have beach chairs and cabanas to enjoy.
We were having a beach day and didn't want to leave the beach. It's great to be able to walk a few steps and get a fresh hot meal.

They do not take call in to-go orders on F-Sun. You have to go to the bar to order to-go. We waited about 15min for our food after ordering. We tried the sweet potato fries, Mahi tacos and the blackened grouper sandwich. Everything had good flavor and was fresh.
We would definitely dine here again!

Caddy's gets 3 stars off the bat for location and views.
Service has always been very good whether it be the bartenders or wait staff.
The food is basic beach fun food.
I have had burgers, fish sandwiches etc, certainly fine nothing will wow you.
Parking can be challenging depending on the time of day. There is a public lot that fills up quickly and street parking is minimal.
Nice to see Caddy's has expanded to other towns close by.
There is always a good vibe, live music and a stellar sunset. I recommend Caddy's!

Our group went here immediately after landing in Tampa and trekking to Treasure Island and then later on during our trip.

Fun beach restaurant and bar that was an easy walk or swim from our cottage. Very easy and casual for a group of 8 to be seated. Come in clothes or a bathing suit it doesn't matter. Music is EXTREMELY loud indoors but fine outside. Had both the shrimp and mahi tacos over the course of two visit during our vacation and both were tasty. Super fast service and nice staff.

Drinks were good, you can keep the bucket or cup it comes in which was a cute bonus. However, the drink prices were not on the menu or not obviously placed which was odd so ordering drinks was kind of a blind process in terms of pricing.

Visited Caddies on the beach on a Saturday evening after spending some time on Treasure Island Beach. The ambience is nice as the restaurant has outdoor seating on the water and also had a live band during my visit. I had a house salad and Grouper nuggets and both were good. I also had a bite of the tropical snapper dinner and the fish did not taste as expected. The snapper lacked flavor. The service was good and the staff were attentive during our visit. Overall good experience.

Kaitlin - thank you for a great afternoon. We got a picnic table for the six of us and had a great time. The drinks were cold, the food was hot and tasty. Try the pork belly nachos and the shrimp tacos. We lost track of how many rounds of cold tasty flavorful drinks we had.
But the quick walk on the beach (with beverages) helped out.
Get here early. Plan to stay late. Pay for the meter so you don't get a ticket.
And ask for Kaitlin