Brothers Gyros & Pizza

Their food is amazing! Every time I go there it's fresh and servings are plenty and you can taste the love they've put into it. I recommend.

Congrats, Brothers, on having an almost *perfect* review rating here. You deserve it!

I grew up in Muskego & Hales Corners, in the 80s, and have lived in the MKE area all my life. I cannot believe I did not try this place until today.

It looks like nothing from the outside. But the food is both INCREDIBLE and very reasonably-priced.

It's the best Greek food in MKE, and on par with the best I've had anywhere. Every type of meat is incredible - beef (which is delicious, medium-cooked steak), gyro, chicken, lamb. My kids declared the fries "better than McDonald's" (which are they're favorite, for good reason).

Every detail is perfect, down to the salad.

We'll be lifelong customers from here on out.

Want a gyro? Yes, come to this place. Drive thru, order/pickup or dine in.

Clean, so very friendly- and fresh and delish food.

The gyros are so good that it's hard to order anything else.

Salads are big, nice veggies, great dressing-

Fries - hot and so so good. My husband always says we can share- but really, just order your own (the basket is big enough to share- if you're into that).

Refills on Coke products (yes!)

Can place an order and wait or just sit down and they'll come and take your order.

I only came in to order to-go, and I felt underdressed, lol! This place is clean, and bright, and has a welcoming vibe to it. I saw what looked like marble in a lot of places and thought, "OOOO, swanky!".

The food is delicious. My husband wasn't that impressed, but his loyalties lie elsewhere. He was willing to try this place out, and will eat from here again, but it's not his favorite.

I love me some gyros, and Avgolemono! All of it here was sooo good, and my only complaint was that the soup had just a smidge too much lemon in it. That won't stop me from getting it again, as I don't know if that is standard for this place, or just a one-off.

The little drive up window near the walk in entrance cracks me up, and I was confused the first time I had to use it, but it makes sense, once you've done so.

This place is pretty close to my house, so I am happy that I don't have to drive too far when I need a Greek fix. 5 stars for that alone, but the food is worth it too!

31/2024

Best gyro meat I have had in the US. The owner is larger than life and is always present. He has a lot to be proud of. Try both lamb and pork gyro meat, the latter one is apparently more authentic. I am on keto diet and they accommodated my request so I got to have both kinds of gyro meat on a bed of greek salad and it was delicious!

It's "only" been 2.5 years since my initial visit, and I regret that so much. Like last time, I ordered a plain gyro, but unlike last time, the pita was not greasy. The meat is outstanding; arguably the best gyro meat I've had in terms of texture and flavor. Even without ordering extra meat in the gyro I feel like there was a generous amount. I also ordered wonton mozzarella sticks, which are fabulously battered in addition to being wonton wrapped.

I've always held Oakland Gyros and Golden Gyros on a pedestal as the best gyros in Milwaukee. Both will need to move over and make room for Brothers Gyros on that pedestal.

All is right with the world....and my tummy when eating at brothers.

You can't go wrong with anything on the menu. The whole experience has tightened up from visits long ago.

Highlights include anything with the gyro meat and my favorite is the Greek street bowl.

The burger is very good and of course the pizza is the best outside of downtown MKE.

Consider yourself fortunate (and full!) if you're able to visit regularly. I know I am. And so's my stomach.

Delicious! Be sure to get a side of red sauce and don't be afraid to add pepperoncinis. They are the perfect addition to the gyros.
I also recommend getting some greek fries!

I used to think all Greek fast casual restaurants (a la Oakland gyros, gyro 27, etc) were all the same. Don't get me wrong, I like those places, but Brothers is NOT the same! It is shockingly better because of the freshness. It is the same gyro or chicken you're craving, but you can really taste the freshness! It's delicious. The meats are all incredibly juicy and perfectly cooked. They have chicken, gyro meat, and pork souvlaki. I was excited to try the pork because not all other places serve this meat option - it was moist and flavorful. Generous portions, too. The menu is extremely diverse, so everyone will find something they like. The service is friendly and quick. The interior of the restaurant is beautifully decorated with Greek inspiration. My friends and I thoroughly enjoyed our meal here. We will be back!

The food is so spectacular every single time we have visited. Everyone working is ALWAYS friendly and goes above & beyond. This place shows a perfect depiction of how true Greek culture is. My partner and I love coming here.