Menu
Popular dishes
What's the vibe?
See all 16
Inside
16 photos
See all 3
Outside
3 photos
See all 99
All photos
99 photos
Location & Hours
You Might Also Consider
in Sandwiches, Delis, Fast Food
in Sports Bars, Seafood, Steakhouses
Amenities and More
Ask the Community
Yelp users haven’t asked any questions yet about Bibinger's.
Recommended Reviews
Overall rating
144 reviews
5 stars
4 stars
3 stars
2 stars
1 star
- Forrest K.WI, WI01Mar 2, 2024
Waitstaff is always wonderful atmosphere great and food delicious, can't go wrong. My wife and I go occasionally for date night and have always left full and happy.
Helpful 0Thanks 0Love this 0Oh no 0 - Marie W.Gray Terrace, Waukesha, WI1215Nov 18, 2023
I could eat here every day! The service was absolutely fabulous- thanks to Danielle! The bartenders know how to make a perfect old fashioned (Crown Royal+sour) & I would highly recommend! They have a drink menu with so many unique ones too! The mushroom risotto with perfectly cooked (medium) salmon was DELISH!!! Hubby loved his chili & we shared brussel sprouts for an appetizer.
Can't wait to go back!Helpful 0Thanks 0Love this 0Oh no 0 - Apr 5, 20241 check-in
Went here for a happy hour after work - didn't realize they don't open until 4:30 so we chatted for a bit in the parking lot before heading in on the dot. They have an extensive line of bourbon/whiskey to choose from, and several creative options for old fashioneds. I tried the tequila and the cherry - both very tasty.
The place filled up FAST for dinner, and it was a Tuesday! We (party of 5) were seated and our server was attentive right away. We started with cheese curds and wings in the traditional buffalo flavor. Both were fine, average. The special for the night was steak tacos, three people in our party opted for those and really liked them. I ordered the pork schnitzel and was very underwhelmed unfortunately. The meat itself was extremely dry and overcooked, as was the spaetzle. What should have leant a nice creamy juxtaposition was gluey and cold. The breading on the schnitzel was falling off and greasy. I ate it but wasn't a fan.
Our server seemed to drop off as it got busier and she knew we had our food. We would have ordered more drinks but by the time the check came the line was out the door so we scooted out.
Fun place for drinks and apps but I don't think I'd come for dinner again.Helpful 1Thanks 0Love this 0Oh no 0 - Apr 16, 20242 check-ins
Nice looking restaurant with plenty of seating. Stopped in for dinner and spent some time at the bar prior to our reservation. The bar offers a large selection of craft cocktails and our group sampled several different types of old fashioned. My favorite was the barrel aged bourbon , not quite as sweet as some of the others and very bourbon forward. The dinner menu was much more casual than expected, they offered a few specials but we went with sandwiches and wraps which were all very good. I heard the fish fry is fantastic and we will be back to give it a try.
Helpful 0Thanks 0Love this 0Oh no 0 - Jeffrey C.WI, WI01Apr 20, 2024
Great service, good food in a nice rustic old inn! Very good old fashion drink
menu. It's fun to just sit at the bar or grab a table for dinner!Helpful 0Thanks 0Love this 0Oh no 0 - Jul 14, 2023
We dined at Bibinger's on a Wednesday at 6pm. We were promptly seated and our server was Hannah who was friendly and attentive.
We ordered drinks and the Brussels sprouts appetizer. They have a good wine and beer menu. The appetizer was good; slightly warm but certainly not hot.
My Nashville chicken sandwich was good but the sides are chips or fries.
I would have liked to order a side salad or a veggie. My wife's berry salad was overpriced for the entree size. Very small, no croutons, 1 sliced strawberry and a small amount of ricotta.
It was pretty loud and difficult to carry on a normal conversation. I don't believe we will return.Helpful 1Thanks 0Love this 0Oh no 0 - B M.Rubicon, WI06Apr 13, 2024
Amazing service and food great bourbon selection easiest to make a reservation to ensure quick seating
Helpful 0Thanks 0Love this 0Oh no 0 - Nov 5, 2022
Fun place to frequent. Great staff. Attentive, friendly, etc. Haven't tried the fare, except the Brussel sprouts, which were great. I have work nearby lately and occasionally stop to sample their fun cocktail menu. VERY attentive bartender (Rowan) and seems well-known by the locals.
The Old Fashions are fantastic. I particularly liked the Cinnamon Apple best; the Cherry Maple is great . . . also tried Strawberry Spice Margurita, though I prefer a more jalapeno flavor, and the Herbal Purple (decent, but they have better options for me, as this tastes like grape Gatorade.)
Also . . . great history. .. . Schwai's before Bibingers. Read about it in the menu!Helpful 0Thanks 0Love this 0Oh no 0 - Benjamin S.West Bend, WI13044Nov 18, 2023
Food is great. Would recommend one of their old fashions before and during the meal. Big fan of the pork schnitzel. My daughter loves their chicken tenders and she eats a lot of chicken tenders. Service is almost always top notch. The only reservation I have about Bibingers is that because it has high/industrial ceilings, it is loud and hard to hear people if you have a group larger than six.
Helpful 0Thanks 0Love this 0Oh no 0
You Might Also Consider
in Burgers, Fast Food
in Delis, Fast Food, Sandwiches