Menu
Popular dishes
What's the vibe?
See all 18
Inside
18 photos
See all 10
Outside
10 photos
See all 83
All photos
83 photos
Location & Hours
You Might Also Consider
in Sandwiches, Delis, Fast Food
in Bakeries, Breakfast & Brunch
Amenities and More
About the Business
Business owner information
Nancy H.
Bailiwick Market and Cafe offers food, art, and events that connect the community to the land. They have locally roasted Milkhouse Roastery coffee, food inspired by local ingredients, artwork by local artists, plus seasonal events for the whole family. Fresh made ice cream is served during the summer. Bailiwick is located in Elbridge, NY on a historic piece of land. The property is adjacent to the plot where the first permanent Elbridge settlers made their homestead. You will find architectural elements throughout the building tying Bailiwick to it's agricultural roots. Elements such as beams from the property's original 1800's farmhouse are integrated into the Bailiwick structure. There is something for everyone at Bailiwick.
Ask the Community
Yelp users haven’t asked any questions yet about Bailiwick Market & Cafe.
Recommended Reviews
Overall rating
67 reviews
5 stars
4 stars
3 stars
2 stars
1 star
- Dec 20, 2023
Title: Community Charm at Bailiwick
Bailiwick Market & Cafe is a delightful community hub where food, art, and events converge, creating a warm and inviting space. The menu celebrates local flavors, and the commitment to the CNY landscape is evident in every detail. It's not just a cafe; it's a place to connect with friends and loved ones, fostering a sense of community. Highly recommended for those seeking a genuine blend of local charm and a great meal! #BailiwickCafe #CommunityConnection #LocalFlavorsHelpful 2Thanks 1Love this 2Oh no 0 - Jan 20, 2024Updated review
I wish we can leave 3.5 stars. Place is a cute set up inside, cracker barrel on steroids. Much cleaner and classy.
Food you go up to the counter a d place an order, receive a buzzer and pick up your food.
Ordered their club sandwich excellent and very large 2 days of food. Lunch the next day.
Steak sandwich was good. They also have great ice cream but passed this trip.
People are not as friendly as previou trip and reason for 3.5 to 4 stars. Asked a woman behind the counter for a plastic to go cup for my spouses water. The look when she handed me the cup was, like a how dare you ask or bother me look.
Hate giving issues in a small business but they need to know. However I would recommend a stop here for food when in the area.Helpful 0Thanks 0Love this 0Oh no 0Business owner information
Emily D.
Oct 18, 2021
Thank you very much! We appreciate your support.
Sep 19, 2021Previous review10 stars or more.
Owner is a sweet young (wink, wink) woman that takes pride in her business and friendly staff.
Service by her team was exceptional. Food was excellent.
Ice cream is really good with great flavors. Bake goods to die for. Homemade chocolate éclair was extra yummy with the cake portion fantastic.
Oh food. Hamburger was cooked to perfection, apple, bacon and maple syrup special. Glad I ordered it.French fries also cooked to perfection.
Spouse thoroughly enjoyed their chicken casadia. Great flavor.
Highly, highly recommend a stop here.
Cute gift shop as well.
Beer and wine also available.
Spo - Dec 30, 2023
I love this cafe. They have delicious farm to table meals, beverages and ice cream. The cafe and market are in a nicely designed barn turned restaurant with goodies everywhere. They are always friendly there and the food comes out fairly quickly. My favorite meal is their chicken pot pie which has the cutest chicken shaped biscuit on top. They also have a variety of seasonal drinks which I love to try, such as their pumpkin chai or eggnog latte. They also have live music which adds to the charm of this great restaurant. One of my favorite things about this place is their ice cream. With flavors like "molasses crinkle" and "just got dumped" who could go wrong? Seriously though, those two flavors are delicious!!
Helpful 0Thanks 0Love this 0Oh no 0 - 1767417Dec 2, 2023
Wonderful options for breakfast here. They have an espresso machine, brewed coffees, teas etc. a nicely filled pastry case. And multiple hot breakfast options. I got a quiche this day too but sadly it didn't make it to get a picture. The quiche portion is a quite hefty portion and comes with a side salad which is always very fresh and a vinaigrette which is to die for. I also ordered the barn door breakfast sandwich which is very delicious. After you order at the counter, you are given a buzzer for when your food is ready and you can pick it up at the counter. The lady behind the counter told me to let her know if I needed anything else in my coffee. Plenty of seating inside and outside if the weather is on your side. Tons of tiny shops of items for sale. Ice cream for sale too. Clean bathrooms for use.
Helpful 0Thanks 0Love this 1Oh no 0 - Jun 13, 2023Updated review
Back to Bailiwick for another treat and a relaxing break on this beautiful afternoon. This business is a restaurant, coffee and tea shop, ice cream stand and gift shop. They make their own syrups for the coffee and tea, their baked goods are also homemade and their ice cream is homemade too!
I had a very tasty tea latte! They steamed strawberry milk and added raspberry tea and
lavender syrup.... sweet, fruity and floral!
The blueberry coffeecake was large, fresh and delicious.
The patio is beautiful and has large awnings for shade, flowers on the stone wall, there is a screened in gazebo and sunny tables too.Helpful 2Thanks 0Love this 0Oh no 0Mar 23, 2022Previous reviewI've been enjoying Balliwick since they opened. I enjoy their food, but today I'm just here for drinks.
Not sure how long they'll have this special, but it is Amazing. Dublin Fog!
Steamed Mint Milk and Earl Grey tea, and some vanilla syrup. The sharp taste of Earl grey goes beautifully withe the sweet minty milk .
I also picked up a delicious blueberry scone. - Jude E.Weedsport, NY16Apr 18, 2024
I'd like to put a five star review but the last several times I have tried to order they refused me. I had called 14 minutes before the evening meal I guess. They said I couldn't order because it was not dinner time. I said when does that happen. She said about 14 minutes. You'll have to call back. So I didn't. I went elsewhere all three times.
Helpful 0Thanks 0Love this 0Oh no 0 - 945310Apr 9, 2023
I've been going to Bailiwick for years. The ambience is amazing! There is a ton of seating especially in the warmer weather as they have ample outdoor seating as well.
They have a full menu for breakfast to dinner. I love their grilled cheese!
The coffee is pretty amazing. I believe it's cafe Kubal coffee. It's rich and deep in flavor.
You'll also find some great baked goods, lots of local foods, local artisans, and other gifts you can buy AND ice cream!!
They also have a drive through.
I can't say enough great things about this place. It's got everything.Helpful 1Thanks 0Love this 0Oh no 0 - May 14, 2023
This is the cutest little cafe! Not to mention the breakfast sandwich was amazing. They sell lunch and breakfast, as well as little treats. They have an ice cream shop here too! You can sit inside or outback on their patio. Extremely family friendly, and all the workers there so so helpful. I can't wait to go back!
Helpful 2Thanks 0Love this 1Oh no 0 - Lisa L.NY, NY066Mar 26, 2024
Nice place . It's like a imitation of Cracker Barrel XM third prices are a little high, but the atmosphere is nice. The food is good although we've only ever gone there for breakfast and the weight staff is pleasant.
Helpful 0Thanks 0Love this 0Oh no 0 - Moose A.Skaneateles, NY123Aug 7, 2023
Great break from the cookie-cutter coffee shops & classic diner menu, although they offer some classics, as well. Ingredients always seem fresh and house prepared. Nice outdoor seating area for those nice days but plenty inside, too.
Huge selection of locally sourced items and food in the retail section.Helpful 1Thanks 0Love this 0Oh no 0
You Might Also Consider
in Breakfast & Brunch, American, Diners
A New Era at Panera with 21 New & Enhanced Options
It's a new era at Panera! Come try our 21 new & enhanced items with more new options under $10*, more new salads & sandwiches & more in every bite**. (*Participating cafes only. Not all items shown are under $10. Prices vary by…read morein Sandwiches