Listed in: Amazing Astoria (NYC-Queens), Foodgasm (NYC), Queens. The Greatest Borough…, Oh You Fancy Huh? (NYC), Si Si Italiano (NYC)
Category:
Breakfast & Brunch
Neighborhoods: Southeast Portland, Belmont, Sunnyside
Listed in: Piggin Out In PTown (PDX), A Bunch of Breakfast (PDX)
Categories:
Performing Arts,
Landmarks & Historical Buildings
Neighborhood: The Strip
Listed in: What Happens Here .. Never…, Being Cheap In Sin City (LV), The Strip (LV)
Category:
Parks
Neighborhoods: West Village, Meatpacking District
Listed in: Chairman of the Bored (NYC), City View (NYC), Parks and Recreation (NYC)
Category:
French
Neighborhood: Greenwich Village
Listed in: The Waiting Game (NYC), Carnivore's Dream, Foodgasm (NYC), Burger Bliss (NYC), La Cuisine de Americana (NYC), West of the Village (NYC)
Category:
Latin American
Neighborhood: Astoria
Listed in: Amazing Astoria (NYC-Queens), Foodgasm (NYC), Boricua, Morena, Dominicano,…, Delicious Dives (NYC), Date Night (NYC-Queens), Queens. The Greatest Borough…, Wepa for Arepas (NYC)
Category:
Steakhouses
Neighborhoods: Williamsburg - South Side, South Williamsburg
Listed in: Foodgasm (NYC), BK is For Brooklyn…, Did You Say Steak? (NYC), Billyburg (NYC-Brooklyn)
Listed in: The Waiting Game (NYC), Foodgasm (NYC), East Village (NYC-Manhattan), Papa Italiano (NYC), Pizza Amore (NYC)
Categories:
Tapas Bars,
Breakfast & Brunch,
Caterers
Neighborhoods: East Village, Alphabet City
Listed in: The Waiting Game (NYC), Mac n Cheese Please (NYC), Foodgasm (NYC), Hangover Heaven (NYC), From A-Z, Alphabet City…, Bunch of Brunch (NYC), East Village (NYC-Manhattan)
Categories:
Bakeries,
Desserts
Neighborhoods: Yorkville, Upper East Side
Listed in: Foodgasm (NYC), Cupcake City (NYC), Decadent Desserts From the…, Happy Birthday Cakes (NYC), Upper East Side…
"Honk if you love peace and quiet."
Loading...
Review votes:
4789 Useful, 1848 Funny, and 3674 Cool
Queens, NY
Yelping SinceNovember 2006
Things I LoveTravel, Jeet Kune Do, Hashbrowns, Karaoke, Yelp, Hole in the Walls, Sushi, Indian Cuisine, Languages, Photography, The Internet, Mexico, Boudin Balls, Kolaches, College Football, Japanese Ramen, Street Food, Hip Hop, Cha Gio
Find Me Ina remote hood in NY. And loving it.
My HometownA place where the air is clean and tacos are only a $1.00
My Blog Or Website When I'm Not Yelping...I'm unpacking my suitcase.
Why You Should Read My ReviewsBecause it might just save your life.
My Second Favorite Website The Last Great Book I ReadJorge G. Castaneda "Manana Forever"
My First ConcertJets - 1986
My Favorite Movie(Tie) Shawshank Redemption / Borat / Oldboy / My Sassy Girl
My Last Meal On EarthA buffet consisting of Korean BBQ, Mexican, Indian, Sushi, and Cajun Food.
Don't Tell Anyone Else But...it's not "Bahn Mi." It's Banh Mi. "Karaoke" is not "kareo-key." It's Kara-OKAY.
Most Recent DiscoveryPeople are giving closed places 1 star, I better give 5 to ones that are open.
Current CrushThe one that appears when you look in the mirror.
I had probably walked by this place over 100 times (no joke) before I realized I was near one of the best (and certainly highest rated) restaurants throughout the borough. It was always dimly lit, quiet from the outside; clearly one of the most unassuming establishments I had come across at the time.
When it was time to celebrate a new milestone, I could think of no other place I wanted to try. There was no point in going the safe route by visiting a place that was a sure thing - being a little adventurous was the right call this time around. Reservations in place, we dressed in our Sunday best and entered the temple of L'incontro. Old school decor, bustling wait staff, and patrons who were all smiles and well behaved.
It was revealed to me long before the waiter would be reciting enough specials for me not to even bother opening the menu. And that he did. I stopped counting after 30 and pondered over my options, enough to where I actually opened the menu for a quick second to see if he had mentioned anything similar. I caved and went for a pappardelle with a rabbit ragu, two things I seemingly can never get enough of. Appetizers included buffalo mozzarella wrapped in prosciutto, fried calimari, and a stuffed artichoke.
Everything was simply divine. The artichoke was by far the messiest dish, a slurpable saucey mess that was surprisingly savory. Prosciutto with any kind of cheese is wonderful, but this was amazing. Even the fried calamari, a bar food dish was crispy and bursting with flavor. My pappardelle was superb. The rabbit was like a tasty stew with just enough sauce not to overwhelm the pasta. Just biting into the noodles, it was clear it was freshly made and had an incredible texture that was oh-so-smooth. The spaghetti wrapped in eggplant was also delicious, extremely fresh, and worth ordering again. At the end of the meal, a complimentary birthday dessert of vanilla ice cream dressed in sweet caramel and drizzled in chocolate sitting on a crispy waffle shell was unexpected but definitely sensational.
I've been back several times since and each experience was always as memorable as the first. I've grown fond of the mezza luna, a ravioli dish stuffed with mascarpone with a walnut brandy pesto, which is simple but scrumptious. Most of their risotto is killer, but my favorite is with pears and gorgonzola. Meats will vary due to the specials and all, but I've had some of the most amazing veal ever in these doors. I can also attest for their broiled lemon sole, which was as tasty as it sounds. Need a showstopper? Try the rigatoni with ground veal and pancetta. Now that's good eatin'.
With impeccable service and incredible food, Trattoria L'incontro has earned my badge of honor as one of my favorite places in NYC. Price points may be a bit high for the variety they offer but knowing this ahead of time leaves fewer surprises at the end of the night. It's been too many years since my last visit to Italy to even dare make any comparisons, but I can say this with confidence: I haven't had better in New York just yet.