Category:
Italian
Neighborhood: Columbia Street Waterfront District
Categories:
Pubs,
American (Traditional)
Neighborhood: Cobble Hill

Dan hasn't made any lists yet.
"Bar Man"
Review votes:
5 Useful, 0 Funny, and 1 Cool
Brooklyn, NY
Yelping SinceJuly 2007
Find Me InBars, mostly in Brooklyn
My HometownMinneapolis
My Blog Or Website When I'm Not Yelping...I am drinking, or writing about drinking, or drinking.
Why You Should Read My ReviewsWent to 1000 bars in one year, I know bars.
My Second Favorite Website The Last Great Book I ReadThe Joy Of Drinking
My First ConcertJethro Tull
My Favorite MovieApocalypse Now
My Last Meal On EarthBarbecue ribs and a beer at Waterfront Ale House
Don't Tell Anyone Else But...I like an occasional drink.
Most Recent DiscoveryCheap Spanish red wines at my local liquor store.
Current CrushBrooklyn Brewery's Local 1
And it really was an oldie, having been around since 1904. This is everything that an old, family run, authentic Sicilian restaurant should be. It doesn't look like much has changed since it opened. White painted tin ceiling, a red, gray, and white mosaic floor, pictures of old Sicily on the wall, just perfect. Nothing overly fancy, that's for sure. But enough neat stuff on the walls and shelves to keep your eyes occupied.
The menu had a lot of interesting stuff on it and it was too bad that I wasn't hungry enough to try more. The Trippa, tripe in tomato sauce with peas looked good and the Vastedda, a Sicilian style sandwich looked interesting.
Don't worry though, they also have a lot for the less adventurous eaters as well. Everything from Penne alla Puttanesca, one of my favorites, to stuffed Calamari. Damn, I am getting hungry just writing this. You don't see Linguini con Seppia (cuttlefish in black sauce) on too many menus.
On our first visit we had the Pulpa all' Insalata, figuring that it would be just an appetizer. This was just excellent. Plenty of octopus marinated in a mild vinaigrette with garlic and some other secret spices. Just delicious.
The Mysterious Chinese Woman kind of put me over my limit. She ordered a rice ball. These are a traditional Sicilian dish and one that you don't see on too many menus. This one was outstanding. It is called Arancina and it is filled with chopped meat, peas and a nice sauce. It is also topped with plenty of cheese and has a tasty tomato sauce poured over the whole thing.
Because it only cost $3.50 we didn't think it would be so big and kind of thought it would be like an appetizer. Wrong. After we shared the octopus salad and the rice ball we were too stuffed to order anything else. It probably didn't help that we got a nice basket of delicious homemade bread as well.
On my second visit here I had the Vastedda which is a Sicilian style sandwich made with spleen, layered with ricotta and grated cheese, and baked. It is served on a hamburger style bun, but they make their buns and all of their breads on the premises and it is delicious. The bun, that is. The rest of the sandwich, not so much.
Now don't get me wrong. I am sure that if you like spleen you would consider it delicious. It turned out I don't care for it that much and it still wasn't too bad. I guess I expected the spleen to be more like, I don't know, a heart or something. A bit crunchier maybe. Spleen is more like chicken livers, both in texture and in taste. And I am not a big fan of chicken livers, although I do like gizzards.
Nonetheless, I did eat the whole thing. Like I said, it wasn't bad, actually okay. Just not my cup of tea.
I am glad I tried it, though, because now I can say that I have had a Vastedda and, if I ever see it on a menu again, I will know not to order it.
The Mysterious Chinese Woman fared much better with her order, sticking with the relatively commonplace Chicken Parmigiana. It came with a generous helping of pasta and a couple of nicely crisped potato croquettes.
Unfortunately, it was kind of blah and the pasta tasted like it had been re-heated. The croquettes were excellent though.
I would still recommend this place though, for the ambiance, friendly service, and interesting things on the menu. Plus it is in an interesting neighborhood that is fun to walk around.