Categories:
American (Traditional),
Diners,
Vegetarian
Category:
Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt
Neighborhood: Mission
Categories:
Office Equipment,
Mattresses,
Department Stores
Categories:
Coffee & Tea,
Breakfast & Brunch
Loading...
Review votes:
58 Useful, 36 Funny, and 21 Cool
Castro Valley, CA
Yelping SinceJuly 2007
Rudy's is clearly very popular. You've got to wait a while for a table and they do pack them in inside. The service was ok, the coffee came in big cups and the decor is probably the best thing about the place. While as predictable as any franchise restaurant that loves its flair, there is a tasteful amount of playful toys and retro-childhood memorabilia frozen in amber (I get it, that's pretty clever) on the tabletops. As well, there are enough stylized American diner cues to have you understand that the place is essentially a diner with a "twist".
So, what's the twist? Well, besides the decor (which, though predictable is impressively tight) the food is not your average diner fare. Yes, there are burgers and such, but the careful attention to detail elevates it above diner and dive status (which is unfortunate because I love that). My dining companion had some Hollondaise-type dish that looked really good, served on a big, fat piece of cristy bread. She seemed to enjoy it and it was certainly presented quite perfectly. I had a breakfast burrito with a side of black beans that was good-n-turrible. The burrito was perfectly rolled up and the the beans and pico were perfectly portioned on the dish. The taste was OK, but really lacking in meat.
I've focused on the aesthetics of the food and overall decor because that's the best thing about Rudy's. What would be great, in my eyes, is if the visual fest at Rudy's was paired with an actual feast of sloppy, more dive-inspired food that was still rich in flavors and inventive in creation. What is served at Rudy's certainly doesn't suck but it is just overwhelmed by the attention to detail and design that creates an expectation for something truly special and just fails in the long run.