3/13/2009
Forrest H. says:
I'm glad I tuned into this wacky foie gras channel...and now I have a brief announcement:
yes, the world is full of problems, and worthy causes to protest...
and just because a person decides to stand outside a Seattle restaurant protesting that restaurants' serving of force-fed bird liver, does NOT mean that they:
a) are undertaking an unfairly targeted protest. Until one of you can show me how to be in two places at the same time...
b) are somehow ignoring other issues that deserve to be protested in our society and world...
or c) are out to "ruin someone's dinner" as has been suggested several times in this thread.
Animal rights is an issue that tends to make people either, slow down and listen, or, act like bombastic fools who are convinced that they are the only "person of reason" amidst people who have "the wrong view".
This goes for people on both sides of any particular animal rights issue, and polarization seems particularly strong in this thread. Have any of you noticed that slavery is no longer legal in this country? No, well, it did happen a while ago...I invite you to read newspapers and pamphlets from the 1840s about slavery. There were many, many writers who spent much ink talking about how slavery was better on certain farms, and that when practiced humanely, that slaves were actually happier than slaves on those "really big plantations."
No, ducks and geese are not human beings. Nor are they "grain to table machines." In the wild, ducks and geese are remarkable creatures. Under domestication, they still have individual personalities, and are capable of understanding when they are being mistreated.
Whether or not you feel that ducks and geese are worthy of being protected from force-feeding practices, the fact that some people believe that they deserve such protection has to do with the evolution of moral cognition in such people: clearly, people who are protesting the practices of foie gras force-feeding feel that it is morally reprehensible to subject the animals to such conditions. Have you ever seen a goose force-fed at close range? No? I invite you to visit a fois gras farm and take a look. Yes, the proliferation of Hungarian and Israeli feeding tube machines may soften your experience. But there is a bigger issue here: do you believe that eating animals who were raised solely to fatten their liver is OK? I do not. If someone, such as the Spanish farm Patería de Sousa, in Spain, that is mentioned in this NYTimes article,
http://www.nytimes.com..., why not show people?
one of the things that you can learn through protest is that some people will be stimulated to act from their baser motives, in order both to advance and oppose the protest. In this thread, I have read some pretty ugly stuff, including some highly inapt and inappropriate metaphors...ahem, those of you throwing around the "nazi" label...