On a mobile device? Try our mobile site, optimized for faster browsing.

Yelp Shadyside

Shadyside Restaurants

Dicarlo's Pizza Shop

1. Dicarlo's Pizza Shop

4.5 star rating
6 reviews

Category: Pizza

(Note: next time I go to Wheeling to visit I will probably get thrown out of town for saying this)  During the 26 years I lived in the Wheeling area, I never understood all the hype surrounding DiCarlo's, and the Elm Grove location particularly. The pizza is good, and it definitely gets points for uniqueness, but it's not the best in the world as many would claim. The non-melted cheese can be…

Best Shadyside Restaurants By Category