On a mobile device? Try our mobile site, optimized for faster browsing.

Yelp New Haven

New Haven Italian Restaurants

L'orcio Restaurant

1. L'orcio Restaurant

4 star rating
14 reviews

Among our favorites for great (but not over-the-top) Italian in New Haven. We actually dined there just before it was reviewed in the Times earlier this year. A pleasant, warm setting and the patio out back is  nice, weather permitting.   Excellent fresh made pasta, delicately and properly prepared. Salads and appetizers are also good.  Wine list is not terribly exhaustive, but that is in scale…

Related Italian Restaurants Searches

Pizza

4.5 star rating
4 reviews

1. Di Matteo's Italian…

user photo

Felt like I was steered wrong by Yelp this time.  Nowhere near the quality of the best of the New Haven area.  I would have much rather driven a few…

3.5 star rating
2 reviews

2. LoMonaco's

user photo

By chance, the company I work for ordered multiple pizza's for us to enjoy. I thought they were delicious and I am hard to please when it comes to…

4 star rating
2 reviews

3. Aniello's Pizza &…

user photo

Aniello's is pretty good pizza when they're on their game. The biggest problem I have with them is consistency. Sometimes the pizza is great, other…

4.5 star rating
2 reviews

4. Mike's Apizza &…

user photo

Wonderful place to eat some great Italian food!  The pizza is good & the meals are excellent. Really no atmosphere to speak of, but it is an excellent…

4 star rating
25 reviews

5. Libby's Italian…

user photo

Not bad for an Italian pastry shop. It was interesting how many flavors of cannoli they serve here. The coconut and the peanut butter ones I tried…

More Pizza in Italian Restaurants »

Pasta

4 star rating
14 reviews

1. L'orcio Restaurant

user photo

Among our favorites for great (but not over-the-top) Italian in New Haven. We actually dined there just before it was reviewed in the Times earlier…

3.5 star rating
12 reviews

2. Scoozzi Trattoria &…

user photo

Scoozzi should be amazing Italian and its menu has so much promise with intriguing flavor combinations, but it's far too overpriced, the service is…

4 star rating
3 reviews

3. Consiglio's

user photo

This is perhaps my favorite Italian restaurant in New Haven.  Around here Italian restaurants are not in short supply and many have come and gone over…

4.5 star rating
6 reviews

4. Skappo

user photo

The stars here don't lie - as of this post no one has given lower than 4 stars, and they're well-deserved.  You would be hard pressed to leave Skappo…

4 star rating
6 reviews

5. Tre Scalini…

user photo

I eat at this place every time I drive from Boston to New York.  It is a gem.  The food has a deep rich authentic flavor, the service is impeccable,…

More Pasta in Italian Restaurants »