Columbus Italian Restaurants

Pizza

1. Mama Mimi's Pizza

Neighborhood: Upper Arlington

I love the concept! It's not delivery, it's Mama Mimi's take-and-bake pizza! And boy, 'tis good! A great idea if I ever heard one, and price is nice.…

2. Figlio

Neighborhood: Grandview Heights

It gets 4-5 stars for the wine bar and wine tasting events. It gets 3 stars for the food.   I have had many great times sharing a large table with…

3. Mama Mimi's Take N…

Neighborhood: Clintonville

I love you, Mama Mimi. When I'm too tired to cook, you are there for me with your fresh toppings and wholesome sauces. When I want that inexplicable…

4. Cottage Inn Pizza

Good Pizza! Good people!  The Cottage Inn Pizza is very very good and a must try. The owner hand delivered our company a pizza and we loved it. We…

5. Iacono's Italian…

Neighborhood: Upper Arlington

I really like this Iaconos location and crave their pizza on a regular basis. Like I've written before, pizza is personal and this is one of my…

More Pizza in Italian Restaurants »

Pasta

1. Pastaria Seconda

Neighborhood: Short North

This is a great place to browse,  I got an order of a beet salad and some pasta, even though the pasta is a bit higher than Carfagnas.  They also have…

2. Salvi's Bistro

For sure, the food here is good. However, this place has no regard for healthy eating in any stretch of the imagination. I would really appreciate it…

3. Figlio

Neighborhood: Grandview Heights

It gets 4-5 stars for the wine bar and wine tasting events. It gets 3 stars for the food.   I have had many great times sharing a large table with…

4. Pastaria

Neighborhood: Short North

Alright, so maybe five stars is a little generous. But hear me out. I ordered the Italian sausage and some sort of spicy sauce and penne. That was…

5. Brio Tuscan Grille

Neighborhood: Easton

This is basically a fancier Olive Garden.  Located in the Easton Town Center, this restaurant is actually very big.  That being said, it has been hard…

More Pasta in Italian Restaurants »