Sublette's Ribs

3.5 star rating
7 reviews Rating Details

Category: Barbeque  [Edit]

924 N 6th St
Monticello, IN 47960
(574) 583-7427
Price Range:
$$
Accepts Credit Cards:
Yes
Parking:
Private Lot
Attire:
Casual
Good for Groups:
Yes
Good for Kids:
Yes
Delivery:
No
Take-out:
Yes
Waiter Service:
Yes
Outdoor Seating:
No
Alcohol:
Full Bar
Has TV:
No
Sort by: Yelp Sort | Date | Rating | Elites' | Facebook Friends'

7 reviews in English

  • Review from Stephen S.

    Saint Louis, MO

    4.0 star rating
    7/27/2009

    Out of brisket! Me and my girlfriend both had our hearts set on it and the dang waitress didnt even bother to let us know. The choppped chicken sandwich was awesome though so I didnt sulk too long.  Jacki's pulled pork sandwich was great too. She had the hot bbq sauce which was really just a little peppery and delicious. The potato salad portion could have been a little more generous, but it was in the end plenty as I got to finish jackis and have some of her fries as well as her little sisters breadstick that came with her spaghetti. who orders spaghetti at a bbq restaurant, oh to be young again.

    Our waitress was really nice (besides the brisket incident) and was patient with us as we werent ready to order numerous times. it was almost 8 and she was not very busy.  she messed up with the tea in too many ways to count but was always apologetic and accomodating to fix things.

  • Review from john h.

    •  
    • 12 friends
    • 69 reviews

    Winamac, IN

    3.0 star rating
    Updated - 5/18/2011

    Here we go yo! Let's see if the food has gotten any better in 10 years.

    Not a fan of the ice tea but the waitress says it IS brewed. Hmm. The ole lady likes it so problem solved, diet coke came quick.

    There is tabasco on all the tables so that's at least one positive thing!

    Hmm....for not being very busy food is taking forever....

    Being atkins ordered the cobb salad w grilled chicken. Very good salad and chuncky blue cheese.

    Crawfish alfredo was deemed "good"

    Mac n cheese and bacon an cheese fries were dubbed. Good but mac n cheese is to stringy.

    Brisket sandwich is "good I ate it all"

    Pulled chicken sandwich is "good"

    Chicken nuggets are "good"

    Maybe a lil better after all these years. We'll have to try again.

    Was this review …?

    1 Previous Review: Show all »

    • 1.0 star rating
      2/9/2011

      Horrible. Wish I could go no-stars here folks.

      New building is nice, sure. but the food has never,… Read more »

  • Review from Chace N.

    •  
    • 1 friend
    • 1 review

    Fort Wayne, IN

    2.0 star rating
    6/16/2011

    Enjoyed the chx gumbo and good garlic mashed potatoes also....However, the reason this place gets a 2 star is because I have had a better quality of rib meat at a diner before that doesn't "specialize" in ribs. If u are going to incorporate the name of your business after a certain food u had better back it up. Sublettes meat quality did not deliver at all. There was hardly any meat on the bones and the bones were tiny. To add insult to injury a half a slab was 12$! I will go back jst to try something different but I will  never get the ribs again unless they change where they get their meat.

  • Review from Diana W.

    •  
    • 2 friends
    • 100 reviews

    Chicago, IL

    3.0 star rating
    9/20/2010

    My neighbors love this restaurant, and we were shocked at the very low prices for a complete dinner entree.  The restaurant decor consists of lots of antiques which makes waiting for dinner a pleasant experience.  The service was friendly and prompt.  Unfortunately, I got a stomach ache from dinner that lasted all weekend so we never went back again.  I have my favorite BBQ places, and I didn't think this was as good, but in Monticello, this is probably the best you're going to get.  It's a great place for family dining though.

  • Review from Stacy Q.

    •  
    • 39 friends
    • 166 reviews

    Indianapolis, IN

    4.0 star rating
    9/17/2007

    A booming little business these days - moved to a new snazzy building and is doing well. I actually do not mind eating here - pretty good food. I particularly enjoy their catering services - the pulled pork & bbq meat trays are always a hit. And the service is always fast and friendly.

  • Review from John Gideon J.

    •  
    • 0 friends
    • 7 reviews

    Chicago, IL

    4.0 star rating
    7/13/2009

    Great food, service and price. Chicken, spare ribs and pulled pork all juicy and delicious. Didn't like the sauces but didn't need them. Good slaw. Grilled corn a great side. Wonderful Texas toast which I usually don't like. My brother liked the fries but I prefer thinner fries although the outside was fairly crunchy. We were too full for dessert but they looked terrific. Rustic family-friendly ambiance that seemed to combine a lodge, antique shop, and taxidermist. My brother said he would drive the 30 miles from Lafayette to eat here again and I agree it was a nice day trip when combined with the Indiana Beach boardwalk.

  • Review from Angie W.

    •  
    • 0 friends
    • 4 reviews

    Poplar Bluff, MO

    4.0 star rating
    1/22/2011

    Clean restaurant if it is summer the patio seating is the way to go.  Good bar.  Salads are great. The buffalo chicken salad is my fav.  They used to have fried pickle slices which were a must have, not sure if those are still being served:(  BBQ is decent quality, flavor ok. Owners are super sweet and usually around. Food comes quick and hot. Good combo.

People Who Viewed This Also Viewed...