Sierra Cup - CLOSED

3.5 star rating
17 reviews Rating Details

Categories: Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt, Coffee & Tea  [Edit]

409 S Myrtle Ave
Monrovia, CA 91016
(626) 301-4214
Price Range:
$
Accepts Credit Cards:
Yes
Parking:
Street
Outdoor Seating:
Yes
Wheelchair Accessible:
Yes
Sort by: Yelp Sort | Date | Rating | Elites' | Facebook Friends'

17 reviews in English

  • Review from Liz G.

    •  
    • 127 friends
    • 81 reviews

    Los Angeles, CA

    5.0 star rating
    5/10/2010

    So sad to see this place go... Daniel played a couple of shows here.  The froyo was tasty, the cupcakes were yummy, the atmosphere was chill and inviting, the staff never disappointed, and they supported local artists.  

    Pinkberry never held a candle to this place.  Now I have no reason to ever step foot in Monrovia anymore.

  • Review from Susan H.

    •  
    • 159 friends
    • 63 reviews

    West Covina, CA

    2.0 star rating
    3/7/2008

    Food:  D+ (for the froyo) and F (for the cupcake)
    Value:  C+
    Service:  A
    Decor:  bland light blue & green indoor with a candle lit patio
    Return Rate:  Will probably update this review once more for accuracy - UPDATED and will only return if my friend wants to play Wii

    Yes, I'm still stuck on the Seinfeld episodes again.  I'm thinking about the episode with the nonfat yogurt ... and when I think about froyo, is it really low cal?

    But here's the low down:

    Froyo did not leave a lasting impression, but it is creamier than Pinkberry.  (UPDATE:  too sweet)

    The mini cupcake ... just no good ... was THIS low cal ... where's the butter?

    The Wii ... good times ... too bad my friend and I like to get each other injured.  (UPDATE:  They have Guitar Hero.  But we couldn't figure it out.  After 3 games with a score of zero ... the kids told us that we weren't strumming ... I was laughing the whole time.)

    Props to joanna e. because I felt the same the way :)

  • Review from Marie Y.

    •  
    • 98 friends
    • 151 reviews

    Azusa, CA

    3.0 star rating
    3/23/2008

    Hmmm...interesting concept for a yogurt place.  Flat screen TVs all along the walls with 2 large ones in front where a girl was playing Guitar Hero on one and two guys were Wii bowling on the other.  

    And oh yeah, they also have yogurt, coffee and cupcakes.

    They have four flavors of yogurt (plain "sour", chocolate, blueberry and vanilla) and lots of fruit and dry toppings.  I ordered my usual, but found that the yogurt was a bit on the frozen side, so it was more like ice cream.  It was still good, though.

    Sierra Cup is a little too busy for me.  Usually, I like to eat my yogurt in peace without having people in the background yelling things in the name of competitive spirit when playing video games.  So I ended up taking mine to go.

  • Review from Jane L.

    •  
    • 14 friends
    • 62 reviews

    West Los Angeles, CA

    5.0 star rating
    2/7/2008

    Was going to go to Coldstone across the street for some ice cream but decided to stop here instead, and oh man was it a great idea.

    Their coffee was good, the hot chocolate was strange in a yummy way, their cupcakes were good as well - yes, it's on the expensive side (to joanna) but if you've gone to the likes of Sprinkles, then no, it's fairly cheap. We played wii bowling for a few minutes and I used the free wifi to check my email on my phone, and then the owner (or at least he looked like the owner, because he was working behind the counter but wasn't wearing an apron or anything) stopped us before we left and gave us this thick pile of like 10 "buy one get one free" cards.

    It's sort of a pinkberry rip in terms of decor and froyo, but it's not too bad. At least it's not an actual Pinkberry :)

  • Review from Danvin R.

    •  
    • 195 friends
    • 273 reviews

    Mountain View, CA

    4.0 star rating
    6/19/2008 3 photos

    I haven't been back to downtown Monrovia in almost a year. Taking a stroll down Myrtle Ave, I noticed Sierra Cup. "Oh, thats new" I thought. It was pretty warm out and that "Smoothie" sign in the window drew me in.

    As I walked in, I was pleasantly surprised. It looked like the froyo places you see in the Silicon Valley; beautiful flat LCDs everywhere, including one being used to display the store's menu. Everything inside was WHITE. I was hesitant to touch anything, afraid of making something dirty.

    I ordered a "Snowboarder" smoothie w/ protein boost. The names of the drinks were all winter sports themed: Snowboarder, Bobsledder, etc. Other than smoothies they serve a wide variety of coffee drinks along with Frozen Yogurt. Prices seemed reasonable (my smoothie was $4 w/ the protein boost).

    This place isn't really about the food they serve though, the atmosphere is what makes this place. There is a Wii lounge (thats right, a Nintendo Wii lounge) to the right as you walk in with two Wii hooked up to HDTVs ready for consumption. In the back there is a patio lounge with nice chillaxing furniture. There is also a stage outside where they host live bands on several nights of the week. Nice. They also have movie nights at the store. Interesting. This place is all about bringing people together and keeping them entertained.

  • Review from Tony Y.

    •  
    • 75 friends
    • 152 reviews

    Alhambra, CA

    3.0 star rating
    4/14/2008

    Mm... nothin' like a hot latte and some frozen yogurt. Latte was ehh.. frozen yogurt was pretty good. Tasted like soft serve ice cream. Mm.

    My Internet was out at the time, so I was driving around looking for free wi-fi. Then I remembered this place because they were passing out fliers for their grand opening at the Farmer's Market. So I drove all the way to Monrovia (I live in Alhambra) just to try this place out, and because I'm so dependent on Internet. I wanna say I was studying and doing homework... but knowing me, probably not.

    So after I connected to their open unsecured network, my laptop just froze. I had to unplug and it and take the battery out to turn it off then restart. Then it started acting all crazy. So this led me to believe that since this was an unsecured connection, someone hacked into my computer and gave it a virus or something, orrrr it was just time for this puppy to go. It said it was low on memory when I restarted it a few times, so I don't know.

    I don't know why I'm telling you this, but it made this place memorable... not really in a good way. But they have Wii and flat screen TVs and a nice outdoor patio area in the back. There was a stage for performers, and couches for loungers. Cool looking place, but I'll probably have to come back here again to really say it's a place worth coming to. They had just opened, and it was pretty dead. I hope they're doing better now.

  • Review from joanna e.

    •  
    • 65 friends
    • 263 reviews

    Pasadena, CA

    2.0 star rating
    11/30/2007

    Uhmmmmmm, Karen and Pete are you related to the owners of Sierra cup b/c really my experience was not as pleasant?

    Though the place is cute, Wii area, cute tables, etc.... but really $1.95 for the smallest cupcakes known to man! I want to say it was about 30% the size of a real cupcake. If you get a real size cupcake it's over $4!

    Also, whatever happened to originality - b/c this place lacks it? It looks like a complete rip of Pinkberry!

    I may give this place another go (before Pinkberry opens)...

  • Review from Reese M.

    •  
    • 28 friends
    • 41 reviews

    Pasadena, CA

    4.0 star rating
    3/17/2009

    This yogurt place was the first place of this kind in Old Town Monrovia.  A year later, Pinkberry decided to plant their seed 2 buildings away from them...meniachal practice, if you ask me.  

    But, I am here to review this place and not to talk about anything else.  I am a huge fan of Sierra Cup.  They have red velvet mini cupcakes and coconut covered ones too....and they're cheap!  They have good coffee and besides their yogurt and mochi toppings, they have a wii inside their parlour where you can play against others or by yourself while you're finishing your yogurt.

    How fun, right?

    The people are super friendly and they have good entertainment on Fridays and Saturdays.

  • Review from David B.

    •  
    • 19 friends
    • 6 reviews

    Pasadena, CA

    4.0 star rating
    12/7/2008

    This place has a pretty trendy atmosphere... about the same as Pinkberry, but with a Wii lounge and an outdoor lounge in the back. The service is friendly and fast.

    The yogurt was very tasty, but the selection of flavors and toppings was kind of limited.

    I was rather disappointed by the coffee. There was a bit of hype surrounding it, and I was let down when the coffee was no better than what you can get at Charbucks. Oh well.

    So the yogurt is good, but the limited selection and underwhelming coffee bring this place down to a 4.

  • Review from Gigi J.

    •  
    • 6 friends
    • 16 reviews

    Monrovia, CA

    4.0 star rating
    4/30/2008

    I have become an addict here!  However, I'm in the midst of a recovery...

    Plain Tart Frozen Yogurt with Strawberry Topping -- A+    The plain tart is great, the contrast with the strawberry strong, and strawberries freeze into the yogurt and get sweetly crunchy.  

    My kids love the chocolate and vanilla yogurts -- and would give them an A -- but I find them too sweet.  My husband likes their blueberry with chocolate chips a lot. The nice thing here is that there are combos for everyone's taste.  

    Signs at the counter say that servings are around 100-120 calories and seem to be made from Mountain High Yogurt (if you believe what I see heading out in their trash -- you see that I've spent too much time there!).  

    I ended up coming here 3-4 times a week for this treat!

    However, it is getting "found" and very crowded and popular, especially with the junior high and high school crowds in the afternoons.  My kids are loving the Wii, but don't like to wait in line for it.  The lounge chairs in the back with the candlelight is a nice treat to sit, read, listen to music in the evenings.  

    I've tried the coffee --ok.  Some people seem addicted to the cupcakes and roll in just to buy a few -- I'm not a public cupcake eater and missed this craze.

    But I'm recovering from the tart yogurt & strawberry combo.  I'm down to only 1-2 times each week.  But I keep coming back...

  • Review from mimi r.

    •  
    • 2 friends
    • 7 reviews

    CA

    3.0 star rating
    12/1/2007

    I came here by chance when I was visiting a friend out in Monrovia.  She suggested to try this place since it is relatively new.

    I am giving it three stars because the decor is just not my cup of tea (no pun intended).  I prefer a nice quiet, simple coffee shop, but hey that's just me.

    I did think the coffee was good, and I was even more excited to see that they serve Auntie Em's Kitchen's cupcakes there (being a huge fan it's great to see their cupcakes in other places).

    Overall the experience wasn't too bad.  But don't just go off my opinions....  it's worth a trip to check out.

  • Review from Pete S.

    Cypress, CA

    4.0 star rating
    11/16/2007

    We came here after dinner from Mikomi's across the street for a cup of joe and some yogurt. As you enter, everything here is clear and plastic, (seems futuristic) with tons ( actually, I think  it was 8) of Vizio LCD TVs on the wall. They even have 2 TVs in the front just to play Wii Sports. The staff is friendly, the coffee was strong.They close at 9 on a Thursday but they were nice enough for us to play one game of Wii bowling after they closed. Great place to go after dinner or after a movie across the street.

  • Review from Jen D.

    •  
    • 6 friends
    • 85 reviews

    Monrovia, CA

    4.0 star rating
    6/17/2008

    I enjoyed the yogurt.  It tasted like good frozen yogurt.  They recently updated their topping lists to include a bunch of awesome sugary ones (I like me some refined sugar).  The back patio is really relaxing; great ambiance.  Note to the owners - maybe you can have them turn the volume down a little?  I enjoyed the ambiance but I had to yell to chat with my friends.  I also would like to see some cupcakes in there that have butter in the recipe instead of oil - much better taste.

  • Review from Brandi R.

    •  
    • 22 friends
    • 18 reviews

    West Covina, CA

    4.0 star rating
    4/5/2009

    I came here specifically for the red velvet cupcakes and although they were delicious i found them to be a bit oily ...but The frosting was very cream cheesey... mmmmmmmmm :-)

  • Review from Bobert S.

    •  
    • 4 friends
    • 17 reviews

    Arcadia, CA

    4.0 star rating
    1/21/2008

    Stopped by the place after a friend recommended it, i thought it was great.  Got a chance to chat with the owners, seemed very nice and considerate.  When I couldn't decide what to get, they were quick to recommend and let us try a few things.  Personally, I like it better than Crack-berry... Hope they are able to continue to do well when it opens down the street.

    I also like the decor, the Wii's are fun, and the back patio has a nice quaint feel to it, they also seem to have musical performances.  Haven't had a chance to check that out yet, but hopefully I will get a chance soon.

    Random thought? Why so many frozen yogurt places suddenly opening in Monrovia? Looks like 3 will be open in a 5 block radius.

  • Review from S S.

    •  
    • 0 friends
    • 13 reviews

    Los Angeles, CA

    3.0 star rating
    8/25/2008

    I didn't get the chance to try their yogurt, though I did visit the yogurt shop up the street called Cherry on Top, but I wanted to mention their cupcakes. I tried their chocolate ganache (mini) and red velvet (reg.) cupcake. I've gone around L.A. and have tried various cupcake shops, like Sprinkles, Yummy Cupcakes and Violet's, and really wasn't expecting much but since it's just up the street from where I work, I thought I would give it a shot. I would say it was fair. The cupcake was on the dry/rubbery side, but I do enjoy their frosting though. It's not too sweet and is not reminiscent of that fake frosting that you get at Sprinkles (though the cake base is better at Sprinkles). The cake part is actually quite similar to Yummy Cupcakes, but it's nothing special. Next time I go, though, I might pass on the cupcake and try their yogurt instead.

  • Review from Diego E.

    •  
    • 20 friends
    • 19 reviews

    Duarte, CA

    5.0 star rating
    2/10/2009

    Yummy yogurt without the sterile/cookie cutter feel of Pink Berry's. They have free Wii for the kids and occasionally have movies and bands in the back patio in the afternoons. It's a great place to go. The people there are always nice.

Deals Nearby

People Who Viewed This Also Viewed...

People Viewed This After Searching For...