Nicole's Pizza

My food wasn't in a bag when the delivery driver came, food should be sealed when delivered. My bun was barely toasted and my burger wasn't well done. I wish they would do better.

I called to order a halal beef pepperoni pizza. They accepted the order. They called me back about 10 minutes later to say they don't have halal beef. I asked for a cheese pizza. When I got to the store 20 minutes later I was told they didn't see my ticket and that they would start making my food now. Very unprofessional. That was my first and last time ordering from them.

So very very happy they are now open in Jamaica Plain. I had cheese pizza with garlic and it was outstanding. I've had their calzone from the South End location and can't wait to have it again. And delivery was superb for us.

This review is for delivery thru Grub hub. First of all grub hub is a nightmare to work with especially when getting it delivered to a hotel. I had to get this pizza delivered twice but luckily I was in no rush. Pizza was yummy and the crust is completely different than most pizzas I have had out here in Boston. Crust is thin and almost airy with a bit of a sourdough taste in my opinion. Not bad and all around good pizza. I can imagine how it would hve tasted hot and fresh.

Kaysan is great delivery driver and the food is amazing and they was very fast with the delivery

Just had Nicole's Pizza delivered, and it exceeded all expectations. The Margherita pizza was a flavor masterpiece - perfect crust, fresh toppings, and melty cheese. The delivery was quick, and Nicole's commitment to quality shines through. It's my new favorite for gourmet pizza delivered right to my door. Already planning my next order!

I ordered an extra large pizza with pepperoni, sausage and garlic.... And got a small plain cheese pizza instead... enough said.

Someone needs to confirm they changed management because this was not the Nicole's I know and love anymore. The inside got gentrified and no longer has the Nicole's feel to it. Also The pizza is not the same, I used to drive over an hour quite often to come get a whole pizza. Very sad :(

Good, consistent pizza and salads. Nicole's offers typical Massachusetts style Greek Pizza - crispy crust that reminds me of the pizza places in my town growing up. This is our go to place when we don't want fancy/yuppy pizzas from Picco or Coppa. We have tried a few of the different toppings on the pizza but always go back to the plain cheese. Greek salad and chicken tenders are also good. Subs are decent as is the burger. Delivery via Doordash has been quick and food arrives hot.

They make really good pizza...much better than the Upper Crust which is just down the street (Tremont). Honestly, give them a try. The Mediterranean is super. We had a bunch of them delivered for a party and they arrived exactly on time and hot. Can't be better than that!