New York Pizza Depot

$2 pizza slice Tuesdays at NYPD might just be the best deal in town! The deal runs all day until 10pm and it's valid on all slices except for the deep dish. They usually have a pretty big selection to choose from but going through the line can be stressful as often times they'll be rotating through options so quickly that they might have a whole different variety when you get to the front.

The line stays pretty consistent throughout the day but I've come to find that the best time is either right when they open or during late afternoon. They have a good amount of seating both inside and out.

The people working are always really nice with a funny, almost NYC style attitude. It really feels like a taste (no pun intended) of home.

The pizza isn't the absolute best I've ever had and Joe's is undoubtedly better in the area, but it checks a box and again, $2 slices simply cannot be beat especially considering Joe's is like $4 for a simple cheese. My favorite slices are the barbecue chicken and the pesto chicken, but again they have a ton of options.

Will absolutely be back!

Working at the hospital night shift, NYPD stays open and delivers late which is nice for us night shifters! Usually get pizza or a calzone when we order. Food is average. But the cheese bread and ranch are really good!! My big complaint is that they always put multiple calzones into one box, which makes it hard to store when you order out with multiple coworkers.

I have been inside NYPD and it's a small pizza shop but cute. Perfect for drunken college students late at night to come in after the bars and get pizza by the slice!

NYPD is our go-to pizza spot in A2. The dine in area is large enough for groups- and it's decorated like we are in NYC. We order up a freshly made pie on the spot, it is served up delicious & cooked to perfection.
My favorite is the white sauce pizza, while my son opts for the yummy Chi town pizza.
My man loves the pepperoni roll.
We can't wait for our next slice!

This place is awesome. When in Ann Arbor go try this place. We always stop here when in town .

This is my favorite New York Style Pizza place.

Value (A+)
$11.50 for two big slices and an order of garlic knots. It's so good and well worth it. Not too expensive

Service (A)
Excellent for a campus town. They quickly reheat the slices you want and call out your order. If the slices are not ready they are super friendly and let you know how long. Remember it's a campus pizza place.

Quality (A+)
The slices are sooo good here. My favorite NY pizza place. They usually have a number of slices ready to go and a great selection. They have perfected the art of campus town pizza slices. The pizza is a greasy unhealthy indulgence at its finest. Now I remember why I weighed so much when living in Ann Arbor.

If your in town or a local go and try this place. You won't be disappointed.

Not bad, it's just the definition of eating food when your really hungry. It's not top tier food but it's like decent food. It's solid.

Pretty average quality/taste but good for that late night quick bite. They offer a variety of specialty flavors, different style pizzas (classic, Chicago style, Detroit style) and other menu items. You can order whole pies or order by the slice. We tried the White Pizza and Mixed Mushroom Pizza.

Beyond good. Ziti and chicken parm stuffed into homemade pizza crust. Ridiculous. Anyone who gave this less than 5 stars does not understand or appreciate New York pizza--and that's not ok. My son's deep dish chicken pizza was also a standout. Great prices. Great service. Family owned...straight from Italy to NYC to---Ann Arbor.

White sauce pizza is amazing! Affordable and convenient for in the run, do recommend

White sauce pizza is amazing! Affordable and convenient for in the run, do recommend

I don't care what anyone else says. I love going here grabbing a slice and a drink. Eating it there. Leaving and feeling satisfied yet not weighted down.

The owner is a nice guy. It's a good place.

This and Joe's should be on your list. Sometimes I'm in the mood for crispy crust (NYPD) or chewy Neapolitan style Joe's.

I was looking forward to sampling a slice of NYPizza Depot and was disappointed. The bearded red head employee thought I was leaving without paying, which should have been a harbinger about the quality, the sauce was bland as was the crust. I'm glad I wasted only $3. If this represents the NY pizza New Yorkers brag about, then their standards are low and reputation is a joke.