Mama Mia's

Good Pizza, fast delivery! Will order again. Thin pizza is very nice included lots of pepperoni.

Pizza is always good and my kids loved the slice. I had the chef salad but it didn't sit well with me I got a little sick. I actually got food poisoning from the chicken chef salad.Service was good waited for a fresh slice. Overall appearance could be updated. The bathroom was clean

NYC food at starving college student prices! Listen, when I go to a town, I make it my mission to find the best pizza, the best taco and the best burger. I was in town for a wedding and Mama Mia's definitely clinches the best pizza around. I'm a Chicago boy but I love my NYC style, too, and this place hits it out of the park. I'm surprised the ratings aren't higher.

The restaurant is located on the Main Street of a cute college town (SUNY Geneseo). At Mama Mia's I ate the Bianca (white pizza with ricotta is how I judge all NY style pizza places), which was rich and garlicky and delicious. The Sausage and the mushroom pizzas were fantastic as well.

The owner, Eddie (from Brooklyn, I found out), was making the pies when I walked in. I saw some slices behind the counter with shaved ham and sesame seeds on the crust. He asked me what I was looking at and I told him I wanted to make sure there was no pineapple. He laughed and said, "No judgement" -- I told him I do judge and I'm glad no pineapple was in sight! He took a slice and heated it up and gave it to me to eat (for free!) while I was waiting for the rest of my order. The sesame seeds on the crust were a revelation!! I loved the place so much I came back a second time a day later. If you are looking for fantastic NY pizza, this is the place. Oh, and the chicken Caesar salad was really good, too.

Amazing fast service for call in at 12:00 lunch.
15min a medium was done. This was the thinnest best pizza I have had in upstate NY in a very long time! Low amount of salty oily cheese, thin crispy light dough, and thin pepperoni! 1 bite... it gets a 8.2 score! Would have been in the 9's if it held a crisp on the undercarriage! Amazing score great freaking pizza. Guy in the front working today was a great fast employee also.

Pizza is amazing! It's incredible! But NYC is the best!!!! Pizza pauls has the thick crust

On a tip from a friend, we stopped at Mama Mia in Geneseo on our way home from Letchworth State Park. We had the super gooey mozzarella sticks, an Eggplant Parm Pizza (made by request), and the Butcher Block Pizza. This is as close to NYC style pizza as we've had living in Upstate/Western NY. The crust was thin, sliced big enough to fold, appropriate amount of cheese grease (if you know, you know). In 17 years of people recommending pizza places that are "really good, no seriously", this was the first one that lived up to the suggestion. This will become a new favorite stop when in the area.

Amazing customer service! Called in for deliver due to us staying at a local winery, they were on time, and professional. Pizza was great after a long days driving on our cross country trip. We had a BBQ chicken pizza and a cheese/pinapple pizza. We also ordered mozzarella cheese sticks. All of which were hot and fresh. Mozzarella sticks were amazing highly recommend! Pizza was fantastic, would recommend as well! Great job team and keep up the great customer service!

All the tables were dirty and sticky. Service was slow
On the bright side pizza was really good and each slice was huge

Great pizza but horrendous service rendered by rotation of college students who would rather be doing anything but wait on you!! Long waits always have worn me out here and was time to move on.

Only moved here a year ago. Couldn't find any pizza around that I liked until my daughter introduced me to here. It's so delicious! I totally recommend!