Gillies Coney Island

4.1.24 @ 1pm - I dined in with two kids and another adult. I ate here over 20 years ago! It's still open and serving delicious food with a smile. We all had breakfast. I ordered steak and eggs, kids had pancakes, mother had french toast. There were lots of sides to share like hash browns, toast, eggs, and even biscuits (waitress was nice enough to throw in the biscuits). The food was so tasty. My steak was moist, perfectly cooked and seasoned. Everyone has compliments to the chef, waitress, cashier, and kind patrons as well. Great atmosphere. Money well spent plus they honor veterans. Thank you!

Dont try to plan ahead and use Door Dash. You will wait in line and your food will get cold as you wait in line for those who order at the drive through. Who orders a full steak dinner at the drive through? The car in front of us did. This isnt Culvers where you are asked to pull ahead. Whoever thought it was a good idea to do drive thru only and not allow people to come in just for pick ups didn't plan it out very well. Just go next door to McDonalds or down the street to KFC.

Orders the fish and chips dinner for one meal and a Ruben sandwich for the other. The fish was soaking in grease and the batter wasn't cooked all the way. So it basically fell off. Fries were cold and hard. Tarter sauce was basically straight mayo. Think I counted 3 pieces of pickle from the relish. The Ruben sandwich had way too much butter and the bread was burnt. It was cold as well is it's curly fries.

This place used to be decent for late night meal but it's really gotten bad this last year.

Sadly after years of coming here and overlooking the mistakes here and there - accidents happen - this time is probably my last time.

When you ask people to order ahead and still allow drive in orders but don't accommodate those who do call ahead, you're going to have a lot of upset people and cold food.

Our server was good, but Don't ever order the shrimp dinner. Just overcooked and seriously awful. Breading was thick and dry, shrimp were tiny.
For a dinner over $14 I would have expected
Dinner shrimp, not over fried hockey puck popcorn shrimp.
Very disappointed.

My go-to for a good sized quality milkshake! Patient staff and decent waiting time(s).

Food and service are great. One of the first places I've eaten when I moved to Mount Morris try the fried green peppers

Good food and service. I haven't had anything from here that I did not like. The only con is that they recently went up drastically on some of their prices so I won't be able to go as often.

It's was ok. People were nice. The biscuits and gravy were soggy. Hash browns were cooked well.

Hold the grease please, your killing the customers !!!
I've been eating here for almost 50 years and not much has changed except everything is so greasy.
Perhaps a remodel is in order?

Why does my taco salad have chili in it ? Like the same chili that comes on the coney dogs

Hit or miss.....I'm from Detroit so moving up here 5 years ago I realized the Coney Islands are so much worse...sadly. But in a pinch This will work. The staff is always super nice and food is out quickly