- Restaurants |
- Nightlife |
- Shopping |
- Movies |
- All
Anthony's Pizzeria & Cafe
- Attire:
- Casual
- Good for Groups:
- No
- Delivery:
- Yes
- Take-out:
- Yes
- Outdoor Seating:
- No
- Has TV:
- Yes
8 reviews for Anthony's Pizzeria & Cafe
8 reviews in English
-
Review from Nice G.
Syosset, NY
2/23/2012
Pizza still the same, but it lost the charm. Discovered this place three years ago by coincidence. Became almost a regular , knowing the servers name and always say hello to the very quite Mr.Scotto AKA Anthony. For a shocking surprise I walked in and I was greeted by a very nice woman, but not a familiar face, looking around I see her husband behind the counter rolling the dough; I asked the server who this people were, she responded, Anthony is gone they are the new owners. The place is call now Rirrro, the new now owners just establish in the country from Taiwan or Korea and are doing a great job keeping the place intact. Still one of the best grandmas pizza in the area.
-
Review from Jordan M.
Levittown, NY
Updated - 4/18/2012
No longer 'Anthony's', it's now a faux-italian place (not run by Italians - no offense) and the food is HORRIBLE. The rookie behind the counter said "New Owner, but Same Great Recipes"., Ummm, no., that's "New Owner. Does Not Know How to Cook.". Apparently Anthony (the original owner) sold the place. WAH! Come back Anthony!
1 Previous Review: Show all »
-
11/9/2009
Truly a Hidden Gem!
This is the place that seems like it's been there 'forever' with little or no… Read more »
-
-
Review from J G.
East Norwich, NY
2/24/2012
Warning to my fellow Yelpers: Anthony has sold. I read the great reviews of Anthony's and thought I would give it a try. I was excited to pick up my Margarita pizza. I arrived and instantly sense there was something up. When I ask if this was Anthony's pizza. I was told It was Vito's. ( sorry i could not find anyone that resembled a Vito) I ask what happen to Anthony. This after a 10 minute Q and A with the owner. i was told they bought it from Anthony 3 months ago. Fast forward to opening my pizza after I got home. The worst pizza I have eaten in a long time. Bad..just bad
-
Review from Albert K.
Syosset, NY
2/12/2012
Introduced to me way back in 2000-2001 by an associates of mine, I've came back here repeatedly for everything and anything on their menu. This is the pizzeria that fostered my addiction to Stewart's Root Beer and to the Meat Sauce Spaghetti. Personally, it's my favorite pizzeria and a great place to go and I would advice anyone to go to this hidden gem.
-
Review from Lisa P.
Syosset, NY
4/29/2009
Just had a few slices so obviously the heating up process made it a bit greasy but boy was it good! You can also eat there if you choose.
I'd go again. :) -
Review from Laura M.
Oyster Bay, NY
12/30/2011
We go there at least once a week. Delicious traditional pizza and pasta dishes . Really like the thin crust pizza w/ the basil and fresh mozzarella and adore the pasta fagioli soup. The staff is friendly and attentive. Very reasonable prices.
-
Review from Howard G.
Oyster Bay, NY
10/13/2011
Super Italian eatery in Oyster Bay...looks like regular pizza place and the pizza is excellent...the real gem are the pasta dishes...superb bolognaise and "alla nonna" dishes...everything very fresh...bring your own wine and Andrea will provide the glasses...best value in the area
-
Review from Ernie C.
Oyster Bay, NY
2/28/2010
Best Italian food in the area
